Quick answer
The KEEN Targhee 2 1014997 is our best overall pick for men who need a waterproof, breathable boot with arch support and moisture-wicking. If you want a non-waterproof option for casual wear and light trails, the Merrell Moab 3 52468M offers medium cushioning and a Vibram outsole.
Our top picks
Best overall
KEEN Targhee 2 1014997
All-around hiking in wet conditions
#2 pick
KEEN Pyrenees 1024654
Rugged trails and heavy loads
Best for everyday casual wear
Merrell Moab 3 52468M
Everyday casual wear and light trails
#4 pick
KEEN Targhee 4 1028987
Long-distance comfort and durability
#5 pick
KEEN Targhee 4 1028987
All-terrain hiking with arch support
#6 pick
Merrell Moab 3 RXZER23
Waterproof protection on mixed terrain
#7 pick
KEEN Targhee 4 1028987
Men's all-weather hiking
#8 pick
KEEN Targhee 4 1030688/1033458
Women's all-terrain hiking
#9 pick
KEEN Headout 1028306
Warm-weather hiking with breathability
#10 pick
KEEN Targhee 4 1028987
Men's waterproof hiking with arch support
On this page
Choosing between Keen and Merrell hiking boots comes down to how you hike and what your feet need. We compared the specifications of popular men's and women's models from both brands, focusing on waterproofing, support, cushioning, and breathability. Our picks are based on manufacturer specifications and defined use cases, so you can see exactly what each boot offers on paper. Whether you're tackling wet trails, carrying a heavy pack, or just want a comfortable boot for everyday wear, this guide will help you decide.
Comparison at a glance
| Model | cushion_level | moisture_wicking | arch_support | gender | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
- | Yes | Yes | men | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | Yes | Yes | men | View on Amazon |
|
|
medium | - | - | men | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | Yes | men | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | Yes | men | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | Yes | - | men | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | Yes | men | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | Yes | women | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | Yes | men | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | Yes | men | View on Amazon |
Best for: All-around hiking in wet conditions
The KEEN Targhee 2 1014997 is a mid-height waterproof boot built for varied terrain. It features a KEEN.DRY breathable membrane and a moisture-wicking lining, so your feet stay dry in wet conditions. Arch support is built in, and the aggressive outsole provides reliable traction. Compared to the Merrell Moab 3 models, it adds the reassurance of a waterproof barrier without sacrificing breathability. It's a solid all-around choice for day hikes and light backpacking.
Pros
- Waterproof and breathable membrane
- Arch support included
- Moisture-wicking lining
Cons
- Cushion level not specified
- Leather upper may feel warm in summer
Best for: Rugged trails and heavy loads
The KEEN Pyrenees 1024654 is a burly all-leather boot with a waterproof breathable membrane and moisture-wicking lining. The premium leather upper provides long-term durability and ankle support, making it a good match for rocky trails and heavier packs. Arch support is included, which helps on long descents. While it lacks a published cushion spec, the sturdy construction appeals to hikers who prioritize protection and longevity over lightweight feel.
Pros
- Durable full-grain leather
- Waterproof and moisture-wicking
- Arch support included
Cons
- All-leather may require break-in
- Cushion level not listed
Best for: Everyday casual wear and light trails
The Merrell Moab 3 52468M is a non-waterproof mid boot with a pigskin leather and mesh upper. It's the only model here that lists a cushion level (medium), making it a comfortable choice for casual walks and light trails. The Vibram outsole grips well on dry surfaces, and the bellows tongue keeps out debris. Because it lacks a waterproof membrane, it's best for fair-weather use, but that also helps it breathe better than the waterproof options.
Pros
- Medium cushioning for all-day comfort
- Vibram outsole for traction
- Breathable mesh and leather upper
Cons
- Not waterproof
- Arch support not listed
- Moisture-wicking not specified
Best for: Long-distance comfort and durability
The KEEN Targhee 4 1028987 is a men's waterproof hiking boot with KEEN.DRY membrane and direct-attach construction, which bonds the upper to the sole for long-lasting cushioning. Arch support is built in, and the all-terrain rubber outsole handles mud and rock. While the cushion level isn't published, the design aims for consistent comfort over many miles. It's a dependable choice for hikers who want a waterproof boot that won't delaminate after a season.
Pros
- Waterproof and breathable
- Arch support included
- Direct-attach construction for durability
Cons
- Cushion level not specified
- Moisture-wicking not listed
Best for: All-terrain hiking with arch support
Another men's Targhee 4 variant, the KEEN Targhee 4 1028987 shares the same waterproof, breathable membrane and direct-attach build as the other Targhee 4 models. Arch support is listed, which benefits hikers with medium to high arches. The lack of a published cushion spec and moisture-wicking detail means you'll want to try them on to gauge comfort, but the proven Targhee platform is a reliable starting point for mixed conditions.
Pros
- Waterproof KEEN.DRY membrane
- Arch support included
- Direct-attach durability
Cons
- Cushion level not specified
- Moisture-wicking not listed
Best for: Waterproof protection on mixed terrain
The Merrell Moab 3 RXZER23 is Merrell's waterproof take on the Moab 3, adding a membrane that seals out water while a moisture-wicking lining manages sweat. The pigskin leather and mesh upper keeps weight down, and the Vibram outsole provides dependable traction. Arch support isn't listed, but the Kinetic Fit insole offers contoured cushioning. It's a solid pick for hikers who want Merrell comfort with waterproof protection.
Pros
- Waterproof membrane
- Moisture-wicking lining
- Vibram outsole for grip
Cons
- Cushion level not specified
- Arch support not listed
Best for: Men's all-weather hiking
The KEEN Targhee 4 1028987 is a men's Targhee 4 with the same waterproof KEEN.DRY membrane and direct-attach build that resists separation. Arch support is included, and the all-terrain outsole grips well. Like other Targhee 4 models, cushion and moisture-wicking details are missing from the specs, but the boot's reputation for out-of-the-box comfort makes it a popular choice for day hikes and weekend trips.
Pros
- Waterproof and breathable
- Arch support included
- Direct-attach construction
Cons
- Cushion level not specified
- Moisture-wicking not listed
Best for: Women's all-terrain hiking
The KEEN Targhee 4 1030688/1033458 is the women's version of the Targhee 4, designed with a narrower heel and different volume to fit female feet. It keeps the waterproof breathable membrane, arch support, and direct-attach construction. The missing cushion and moisture-wicking specs are a drawback, but the gender-specific fit and proven traction make it a strong candidate for women who hike in wet, uneven terrain.
Pros
- Waterproof KEEN.DRY membrane
- Arch support included
- Women's specific fit
Cons
- Cushion level not specified
- Moisture-wicking not listed
Best for: Warm-weather hiking with breathability
The KEEN Headout 1028306 stands out with a breathable mesh lining that helps keep feet cool in warmer environments, while still offering a KEEN.DRY waterproof membrane. Arch support is included, and the leather-and-mesh upper balances durability with airflow. It's a smart pick for summer hikes where you might encounter stream crossings but don't want a fully sealed leather boot.
Pros
- Waterproof yet breathable mesh lining
- Arch support included
- Leather and mesh upper for ventilation
Cons
- Cushion level not specified
- Moisture-wicking not listed
Best for: Men's waterproof hiking with arch support
The KEEN Targhee 4 1028987 is another men's Targhee 4 variant, offering the same waterproof membrane, arch support, and direct-attach build. It's a straightforward, no-frills hiking boot for men who want reliable waterproofing and support. As with the other Targhee 4 models, cushion and moisture-wicking specs aren't published, so in-store fitting is recommended.
Pros
- Waterproof and breathable
- Arch support included
- Direct-attach construction
Cons
- Cushion level not specified
- Moisture-wicking not listed
How to choose
Waterproofing: Do you need it?
Waterproof boots use a membrane like KEEN.DRY or Merrell's waterproof membrane to block water while allowing sweat vapor to escape. The KEEN Targhee 2 1014997 and Merrell Moab 3 RXZER23 both feature this technology, making them suitable for wet trails and stream crossings. If you hike mostly in dry weather, a non-waterproof boot like the Merrell Moab 3 52468M can be lighter and more breathable. Always check for a waterproof rating if you expect rain or snow.
Cushioning and support for long hikes
Cushioning affects all-day comfort, especially on hard-packed trails. Only the Merrell Moab 3 52468M lists a cushion level (medium), while most KEEN models omit this spec. That doesn't mean they lack cushioning, but you'll need to try them on. For long miles, look for boots with a supportive midsole and a removable insole so you can add your own orthotics if needed.
Fit and gender-specific design
A boot that fits well prevents blisters and hot spots. Both brands offer men's and women's specific models, like the KEEN Targhee 4 1030688/1033458 for women. Arch support is listed on several KEEN boots, including the KEEN Targhee 2 1014997, which can help if you have flat feet. Merrell's Kinetic Fit insole in the Merrell Moab 3 52468M provides contoured support. Always check the gender and arch support specs to match your foot shape.
Breathability and moisture management
Moisture-wicking linings pull sweat away from your skin, keeping feet drier and reducing blister risk. The KEEN Targhee 2 1014997 and KEEN Pyrenees 1024654 both include this feature. In warm weather, a boot with mesh panels, like the KEEN Headout 1028306, adds ventilation. If your feet sweat a lot, prioritize moisture-wicking and avoid all-leather boots without a breathable membrane.
Frequently asked questions
Which is lighter, Keen or Merrell hiking boots?
Neither brand publishes specific weight data for these models, but the non-waterproof Merrell Moab 3 52468M is likely lighter than the leather KEEN boots. If weight is a priority, look for boots with more mesh and fewer leather panels.
Are Merrell Moab 3 boots waterproof?
The waterproof models, like the KEEN Targhee 2 1014997 and Merrell Moab 3 RXZER23, use a breathable membrane to keep water out while letting sweat escape. The Merrell Moab 3 52468M is not waterproof, so it's best for dry conditions or casual use.
Do Keen or Merrell boots need to be broken in?
All-leather boots like the KEEN Pyrenees 1024654 may need a short break-in period. The mesh and leather models from both brands are generally comfortable right out of the box, especially the Merrell Moab 3 52468M with its medium cushioning.
Which brand has better arch support?
Both brands offer arch support in many models. The KEEN Targhee 2 1014997 and KEEN Targhee 4 1030688/1033458 include it, while the Merrell Moab 3 52468M does not list it. If you need extra support, check the spec for arch support before buying.
Bottom line
If you need a reliable all-around waterproof boot, KEEN Targhee 2 1014997 is our top pick. For casual wear and light trails, the non-waterproof Merrell Moab 3 52468M offers medium cushion and everyday comfort. Hikers who prioritize durability and support on rough terrain will appreciate the all-leather KEEN Pyrenees 1024654, while the KEEN Targhee 4 1030688/1033458 gives women a purpose-built fit. The KEEN Headout 1028306 stands out for warm-weather breathability.