Best Trail Running Shoes for Underpronation

We earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. Learn more.

Quick answer

The Asics Gel-Nimbus 28 1012B899-001 is our top pick for runners with underpronation, offering soft PureGEL cushioning that absorbs shock well. If you want a lighter shoe for speed, consider the ASICS NOVABLAST 5 1011B974-403.

Our top picks

On this page
  1. Our top picks
  2. Comparison
  3. 1. 1012B899-001
  4. 2. 1011B974-403
  5. 3. 1011B974.250
  6. 4. MTHIERO9-318
  7. 5. WTHIERG9-820
  8. 6. WTNTRGP6
  9. 7. 120464 1B 037
  10. 8. 110475 1D 080
  11. 9. 110441-407
  12. 10. 1011C164.400
  13. 11. AL0A85PR/AL0A85PS220
  14. 12. S20744-14
  15. 13. AL0A85ND
  16. How to choose
  17. FAQ
  18. Bottom line

If you have underpronation (supination), you need trail running shoes with generous cushioning and flexibility to help absorb impact and promote a smooth stride. We compared specifications like weight, upper material, and breathability across leading models to find the best options for your gait and the trails you run. Our picks are based on published specs and defined use cases, so you can choose with confidence.

Comparison at a glance

Key specs ยท full specs in each pick
Model shaft_height upper_material weight breathable Link
ASICS Women's Gel-Nimbus 28 Running Shoes 1012B899-001 - synthetic 23.04 oz Yes View on Amazon
ASICS Men's NOVABLAST 5 Running Shoes 1011B974-403 - mesh 23.04 oz Yes View on Amazon
ASICS Women's NOVABLAST 5 Running Shoes 1011B974.250 - mesh 23.04 oz Yes View on Amazon
New Balance Men's Fresh Foam X Hierro V9 MTHIERO9-318 - mesh 33.6 oz Yes View on Amazon
New Balance Women's Fresh Foam X Hierro V9 WTHIERG9-820 - mesh 33.6 oz Yes View on Amazon
New Balance Women's Dynasoft Nitrel V6 Trail Running Shoes WTNTRGP6 - mesh 33.6 oz - View on Amazon
Brooks Women's Ghost Trail Running Shoe 120464 1B 037 - mesh - Yes View on Amazon
Brooks Men's Ghost Trail Running Shoe 110475 1D 080 - mesh - Yes View on Amazon
Brooks Men's Catamount 4 Speed Trail Running Shoe 110441-407 - mesh - Yes View on Amazon
ASICS Men's Trabuco MAX 5 Trail Running Shoes 1011C164.400 low mesh - - View on Amazon
ALTRA Women's Lone Peak 9 Trail Running Shoe AL0A85PR/AL0A85PS220 - mesh - - View on Amazon
Saucony Men's Excursion TR16 Trail Running Shoe S20744-14 - mesh - - View on Amazon
ALTRA Women's Lone Peak 8 Trail Running Shoe AL0A85ND - mesh - - View on Amazon
ASICS Women's Gel-Nimbus 28 Running Shoes
Best overall

1. Asics Gel-Nimbus 28 1012B899-001

upper_material synthetic outsole_material rubber weight 23.04 oz

Best for: Long runs on moderate trails with cushioning priority

The Asics Gel-Nimbus 28 1012B899-001 earns the top spot for underpronators thanks to its engineered knit upper and PureGEL cushioning that provides soft, shock-absorbing landings. With a weight of 23.04 oz and a breathable synthetic mesh upper, it keeps feet comfortable on long runs. The rubber outsole offers reliable traction on varied terrain. This is a neutral shoe best suited for runners who want plush comfort over distance.

Pros

  • Plush PureGEL cushioning absorbs shock
  • Lightweight at 23.04 oz
  • Breathable upper keeps feet cool
  • Lace-up closure for secure fit

Cons

  • Lacks aggressive tread for technical trails
  • Not designed for stability needs
Full specifications (5)
upper_material
synthetic
outsole_material
rubber
weight
23.04 oz
breathable
Yes
closure_type
lace-up

Specs: Amazon listing

ASICS Men's NOVABLAST 5 Running Shoes
Best for fast and light

2. ASICS NOVABLAST 5 1011B974-403

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber weight 23.04 oz

Best for: Fast trail runs and races on smooth trails

The ASICS NOVABLAST 5 1011B974-403 is built for speed with a breathable engineered mesh upper and FF BLAST MAX cushioning that delivers an energized ride. At 23.04 oz, it's one of the lighter options on this list, making it ideal for tempo runs and racing on trails. The rubber outsole provides grip, though the shoe is best on non-technical terrain. Runners with underpronation will appreciate the responsive yet soft feel.

Pros

  • Very lightweight at 23.04 oz
  • Energetic FF BLAST MAX cushioning
  • Breathable mesh upper

Cons

  • Less cushioning than plush models
  • Not ideal for rocky, technical trails
Full specifications (4)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
weight
23.04 oz
breathable
Yes

Specs: Amazon listing

ASICS Women's NOVABLAST 5 Running Shoes
Lowest weight

3. Asics NOVABLAST 5 1011B974.250

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber weight 23.04 oz

Best for: Fast, lightweight runs on packed trails

The Asics NOVABLAST 5 1011B974.250 shares the same FF BLAST MAX cushioning and trampoline-inspired outsole as the NOVABLAST 5 but is listed at a slightly different weight. Its breathable engineered mesh upper and rubber outsole make it a versatile trail shoe. It is among the lightest options, making it a strong candidate for underpronators who prioritize speed and a responsive toe-off. The tongue wing construction helps secure the midfoot.

Pros

  • Lowest weight among picks
  • Responsive bounce-back from outsole
  • Breathable mesh upper

Cons

  • Lacks closure type info for fit assurance
  • Not for technical or muddy trails
Full specifications (4)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
weight
23.04 oz
breathable
Yes

Specs: Amazon listing

New Balance Men's Fresh Foam X Hierro V9
#4 pick

4. New Balance Fresh Foam X Hierro MTHIERO9-318

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber weight 33.6 oz

Best for: Technical trail runs on rocky or uneven terrain

The New Balance Fresh Foam X Hierro MTHIERO9-318 is a trail shoe built for rugged terrain with a dual-density Fresh Foam X midsole and a Vibram Megagrip outsole. At 33.6 oz, it's heavier than the Asics models but offers exceptional traction and stability on uneven ground. The breathable knit upper adds comfort. Underpronators who venture onto technical trails will appreciate the grip and protective cushioning, though the weight may feel heavy for speed work.

Pros

  • Vibram Megagrip outsole for rugged trails
  • Dual-density midsole for comfort and stability
  • Breathable knit upper

Cons

  • Heavier at 33.6 oz
  • Less flexible for fast running
Full specifications (5)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
weight
33.6 oz
breathable
Yes
closure_type
lace-up

Specs: Amazon listing

New Balance Women's Fresh Foam X Hierro V9
#5 pick

5. New Balance Fresh Foam X Hierro V9

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber weight 33.6 oz

Best for: Technical off-road trails with steep, loose terrain

The New Balance Fresh Foam X Hierro V9 is another trail shoe from New Balance with a dual-density Fresh Foam X midsole and Vibram Megagrip outsole. At 33.6 oz, it shares the same weight as the Hierro model and offers similar off-road capability. The breathable mesh upper keeps feet comfortable. For underpronators who need reliable traction on steep, loose trails, this shoe delivers, but the weight may not suit runners aiming for speed records.

Pros

  • Excellent Vibram Megagrip traction
  • Plush Fresh Foam X cushioning
  • Breathable mesh upper

Cons

  • Heavy at 33.6 oz
  • Not a lightweight feel
Full specifications (5)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
weight
33.6 oz
breathable
Yes
closure_type
lace-up

Specs: Amazon listing

New Balance Women's Dynasoft Nitrel V6 Trail Running Shoes
#6 pick

6. New Balance Dynasoft Nitrel V6 WTNTRGP6

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber weight 33.6 oz

Best for: Mixed terrain runs road-to-trail transitions

The New Balance Dynasoft Nitrel V6 WTNTRGP6 features a DynaSoft midsole that balances responsiveness and comfort, making it a good choice for runners who want a versatile shoe for both on and off-road use. At 33.6 oz, it is in the heavier camp. The mesh upper and lace-up closure provide a standard fit. Underpronators looking for a budget-friendly option with decent cushioning and an AT Tread outsole for mixed terrain may find this shoe adequate, though it lacks the advanced cushioning of premium models.

Pros

  • Versatile AT Tread outsole for road and trail
  • Responsive DynaSoft midsole
  • Lace-up closure for secure fit

Cons

  • Heavy at 33.6 oz
  • Not as breathable (breathable data missing)
Full specifications (4)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
weight
33.6 oz
closure_type
lace-up

Specs: Amazon listing

Brooks Women's Ghost Trail Running Shoe
#7 pick

7. Brooks Ghost Trail 120464 1B 037

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber breathable Yes

Best for: Dry, rocky, and technical trail runs

The Brooks Ghost Trail 120464 1B 037 is designed for dry, rocky, and technical terrain with a nitrogen-infused midsole and TrailTack rubber outsole for grip. Its breathable mesh upper keeps feet cool. Weight is not specified, but the shoe prioritizes durability and traction over lightness. Underpronators who tackle technical trails will appreciate the all-terrain grip and plush cushioning that helps absorb shock on hard landings. The shoe is built to handle the toughest conditions.

Pros

  • TrailTack rubber outsole for dry, rocky trails
  • Nitrogen-infused cushioning for comfort
  • Breathable mesh upper

Cons

  • Weight not listed for comparison
  • Not ideal for wet or muddy conditions
Full specifications (4)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
breathable
Yes
closure_type
lace-up

Specs: Amazon listing

Brooks Men's Ghost Trail Running Shoe
#8 pick

8. Brooks Ghost Trail 110475 1D 080

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber breathable Yes

Best for: Technical, dry trail runs for men

The Brooks Ghost Trail 110475 1D 080 is the men's version of the Ghost Trail, featuring a breathable air mesh upper and TrailTack rubber outsole for off-road grip. Designed for dry, rocky, and technical terrain, it offers the trusted comfort of the Ghost series. Underpronators will find the cushioning adequate for shock absorption, though weight is not specified. This shoe is a solid choice for trail runners who need a durable, protective shoe for challenging terrain.

Pros

  • TrailTack outsole for technical terrain
  • Breathable air mesh upper
  • Comfortable cushioning from Ghost series

Cons

  • Weight not listed for comparison
  • Not designed for wet conditions
Full specifications (4)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
breathable
Yes
closure_type
lace-up

Specs: Amazon listing

Brooks Men's Catamount 4 Speed Trail Running Shoe
#9 pick

9. Brooks Catamount 4 Speed 110441-407

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber breathable Yes

Best for: Speed-focused trail runs with climbs and descents

The Brooks Catamount 4 Speed 110441-407 is a speed-focused trail shoe from Brooks, featuring a SkyVault Trail Plate, DNA FLASH v2 midsole for high energy return, and TrailTack Green rubber outsole. The single-layer mesh upper is breathable. Underpronators who want a fast, responsive shoe for climbing and descending will appreciate the plate-driven propulsion. Weight is not listed, but it is designed for speed. The shoe excels on dry, technical trails where traction and energy return matter.

Pros

  • SkyVault Trail Plate for speed on climbs
  • DNA FLASH v2 high energy return
  • TrailTack Green rubber for wet/dry traction

Cons

  • Weight not listed for comparison
  • Aggressive fit may not suit all feet
Full specifications (3)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
breathable
Yes

Specs: Amazon listing

ASICS Men's Trabuco MAX 5 Trail Running Shoes
#10 pick

10. ASICS Trabuco MAX 5 1011C164.400

shaft_height low upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber

Best for: Wet or damp trail conditions with moderate terrain

The ASICS Trabuco MAX 5 1011C164.400 offers a water-repellent mesh upper and FF BLAST PLUS cushioning for a responsive ride. The GUIDESOLE technology helps reduce fatigue by promoting a natural rolling motion. Underpronators will benefit from the soft cushioning and smooth transition. The low shaft height and lace-up closure provide a secure fit. This shoe is best for moderate trails and wet conditions, though weight is not specified.

Pros

  • Water-repellent mesh upper
  • FF BLAST PLUS cushioning for responsive comfort
  • GUIDESOLE technology for smooth rides

Cons

  • Weight not listed
  • Breathability may be compromised with water-repellent coating
Full specifications (4)
shaft_height
low
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
closure_type
lace-up

Specs: Amazon listing

ALTRA Women's Lone Peak 9 Trail Running Shoe
#11 pick

11. Altra Lone Peak 9 AL0A85PR/AL0A85PS220

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber closure_type lace-up

Best for: Runners who prefer wide toe boxes and zero-drop platforms

The Altra Lone Peak 9 AL0A85PR/AL0A85PS220 features a ripstop mesh upper, Altra EGO midsole for cushioning, and a DuraTread outsole with TrailClaw lugs for traction. It has a lace-up closure. Underpronators who prefer a roomy toe box and zero-drop platform (typical of Altra) will find this shoe accommodating. Weight and breathability are not specified, but the shoe is built for stability on technical trails. It suits runners who want a natural foot position and ample cushioning.

Pros

  • Roomy toe box for toe splay
  • Altra EGO midsole for cushioning
  • DuraTread outsole with TrailClaw lugs

Cons

  • Weight not listed for comparison
  • Breathability data missing
Full specifications (3)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
closure_type
lace-up

Specs: Amazon listing

Saucony Men's Excursion TR16 Trail Running Shoe
#12 pick

12. Saucony Excursion TR16 S20744-14

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber closure_type lace-up

Best for: Budget-friendly trail runs on moderate terrain

The Saucony Excursion TR16 S20744-14 offers VERSARUN cushioning for balanced comfort and grippy carbon-rubber lugs for traction on varied terrain. Its mesh upper and lace-up closure provide a standard fit. Underpronators on a budget or looking for a simple, durable shoe for easy trails will find this a functional choice. Weight and breathability are not specified, but the outsole is designed to grip well on loose surfaces. It lacks the advanced cushioning of premium models.

Pros

  • Grippy carbon-rubber lugs for traction
  • VERSARUN cushioning for all-day comfort
  • Lace-up closure for secure fit

Cons

  • Weight and breathability not listed
  • Less advanced cushioning than top picks
Full specifications (3)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber
closure_type
lace-up

Specs: Amazon listing

ALTRA Women's Lone Peak 8 Trail Running Shoe
#13 pick

13. ALTRA Lone Peak 8 AL0A85ND

upper_material mesh outsole_material rubber

Best for: Technical trails requiring foot protection and toe splay

The ALTRA Lone Peak 8 AL0A85ND features Altra's FootShape fit with a roomy toe box and a StoneGuard for underfoot protection. The ripstop mesh upper is durable. Underpronators who value toe splay and natural movement will appreciate the design. Weight, breathability, and closure type are not specified, but the shoe is aimed at trail runners who want a protective, foot-shaped shoe. It is best suited for technical trails where underfoot debris is common.

Pros

  • Roomy toe box for natural foot splay
  • StoneGuard for underfoot protection
  • Durable ripstop mesh upper

Cons

  • Weight and breathability not listed
  • No closure type specified for fit
Full specifications (2)
upper_material
mesh
outsole_material
rubber

Specs: Amazon listing

How to choose

Cushioning and shock absorption

Underpronators strike on the outside of the foot and need ample cushioning to absorb impact. Look for shoes with soft midsole materials like PureGEL, FF BLAST, or Fresh Foam X. Plush cushioning helps reduce stress on joints and promotes a more comfortable ride. Avoid overly firm shoes that don't provide enough give on hard landings.

Weight and breathability

Lighter shoes like the ASICS NOVABLAST 5 1011B974-403 and Asics NOVABLAST 5 1011B974.250 reduce fatigue on long runs. Breathable uppers, indicated by mesh materials, keep feet cool and prevent overheating. If you prioritize speed, go for a lightweight model. For rugged trails, slightly heavier shoes with better traction may be worth the trade-off.

Traction and outsole design

The outsole determines grip on different surfaces. For dry, rocky trails, look for rubber compounds like Vibram Megagrip or TrailTack. For loose or muddy terrain, deeper lugs (like on the Altra models) provide better bite. Consider where you run most and choose an outsole that matches the terrain.

Fit and closure system

A secure fit is crucial for stability. Most shoes use lace-up closures, which allow you to customize tightness. Some models (like the Altra Lone Peak) offer a roomy toe box that lets toes splay naturally, beneficial for underpronators who need space. If you have narrow feet, look for shoes with a more tapered fit or use the lacing system to lock down the heel.

Terrain and use case

Match the shoe to the trails you run. For smooth, packed trails, lightweight shoes with moderate tread work well. For technical, rocky singletrack, choose a shoe with a protective toe cap, stone guard, and aggressive outsole. The New Balance Hierro models and Brooks Ghost Trail are built for rugged conditions, while the Asics options are better for less demanding terrain.

Frequently asked questions

What is underpronation and why does it matter for trail running shoes?

Underpronation, or supination, is when your foot rolls outward upon landing. Runners with underpronation need shoes with soft, neutral cushioning to absorb shock and promote a smoother gait. Look for flexible midsoles that encourage a natural foot motion.

Do I need stability shoes for underpronation?

No, stability shoes are designed for overpronation. Underpronators should avoid rigid medial posts and seek neutral shoes with generous cushioning. All the picks on this page are neutral shoes suitable for underpronation.

How do I know if a trail running shoe has enough cushioning for underpronation?

Check the midsole technology: terms like PureGEL, FF BLAST, Fresh Foam X, or DNA FLASH v2 generally indicate soft, responsive cushioning. The shoe's weight can also be a clue; heavier shoes often have more cushioning material.

Is a low weight more important than traction for underpronators?

It depends on the terrain. On smooth trails, lighter weight helps efficiency. On technical terrain, traction is more critical to prevent slipping. If you run on both, look for a balanced shoe like the New Balance Hierro that combines decent weight with aggressive grip.

Can I use these shoes for road running if I have underpronation?

Many trail shoes can double as road shoes for short distances, but they have chunkier outsoles that may feel less smooth on pavement. If you mostly run roads, consider dedicated road shoes with softer cushioning. For mixed routes, options like the New Balance Dynasoft Nitrel V6 WTNTRGP6 with AT Tread outsole work well.

Bottom line

For most underpronators, the Asics Gel-Nimbus 28 1012B899-001 offers the best balance of cushioning and lightness for long trail runs. If speed is your priority, the ASICS NOVABLAST 5 1011B974-403 provides a responsive feel at a lower weight. For technical terrain, the New Balance Fresh Foam X Hierro MTHIERO9-318 delivers superior traction. Choose based on the trails you run and the feel you prefer.