Quick answer
The Columbia Crestwood 178118 is our top pick for hiking shoes that accommodate custom orthotics. At just 20 oz, it is lightweight and breathable. For fast-and-light trips, consider the OrthoComfoot Women's Orthopedic Hiking Boots with its supportive insole system.
Our top picks
Best overall
Columbia Crestwood 178118
Day hikes and fast-paced trails
#2 pick
Merrell Moab 3 J035896
Rugged terrain requiring ankle stability
Best for fast and light
OrthoComfoot Women's Orthopedic Hiking Boots
Fast and light hiking with orthotic support
Best for backpacking
Merrell Moab 3 RXZER23
Backpacking with waterproof needs
#5 pick
Orthofeet Carmel
Easy-access waterproof hiking with orthotics
#6 pick
OrthoComfoot Men's Orthopedic Wide Barefoot Shoes
Barefoot-style fast hiking with orthotics
#7 pick
OrthoComfoot Men's Orthopedic Wide Waterproof Hiking Boots
Waterproof backpacking with orthopedic support
#8 pick
Orthofeet Alma
Fast and light in variable weather
#9 pick
OrthoComfoot Orthopedic Wide Waterproof Hiking Boots
All-day comfort on moderate trails
#10 pick
OrthoComfoot Women's Wide Orthopedic Trail Running Shoes
Fast and light trail running with orthotics
#11 pick
OrthoComfoot Men's Wide Orthopedic Plantar Fasciitis Shoes
Plantar fasciitis relief on fast hikes
#12 pick
OrthoComfoot Men's Orthopedic Wide Trail Running Shoes
Warm-weather fast hiking with orthotics
#13 pick
Orthofeet Avalon 614415044964
Wet-weather day hikes with orthotics
On this page
If you need custom orthotics, finding hiking shoes with a removable insole and a roomy toe box is essential. Too many shoes force you to choose between ankle support and enough space for your inserts. We compared the specifications of the top hiking shoe models against these needs. Our picks are based on published specs, including weight, shaft height, waterproofing, and breathability. Whether you are day hiking, backpacking, or moving fast and light, there is a shoe here that can work with your orthotics. Our best female beginner hiking boots guide also highlights beginner-friendly options.
Comparison at a glance
Key specs · full specs in each pick| Model | waterproof | shaft_height | upper_material | outsole_material | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
- | low | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | high | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | high | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | mid | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | high | leather | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | mesh | eva | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | mid | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | - | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | high | synthetic | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | mesh | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | combination | eva | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | synthetic | rubber | View on Amazon |
Best for: Day hikes and fast-paced trails
The Columbia Crestwood 178118 is a lightweight leather and mesh hiking shoe that weighs just 20 oz. Its low shaft allows easy movement, while the breathable mesh helps keep feet dry on warm trails. The rubber outsole provides solid traction on moderate terrain. This shoe works well for day hikes and fast-and-light hikes when you need a removable insole for custom orthotics. On paper, it is the lightest shoe in our lineup, making it ideal for minimalists.
Pros
- Lightweight at 20 oz
- Breathable design
- Low shaft for agility
Cons
- Not waterproof
- Low shaft offers less ankle support
Full specifications (5)
- shaft_height
- low
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
- weight
- 20 oz
- breathable
- Yes
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Rugged terrain requiring ankle stability
The Merrell Moab 3 J035896 is a heavy-duty high-shaft boot from Merrell with a rubber outsole and lace-up closure. At 48.96 oz, it is one of the heaviest models in our comparison, offering maximum ankle support for rough terrain. Its high shaft and sturdy construction may suit hikers who prioritize stability over weight. The removable insole can accommodate custom orthotics, but the boot's bulk makes it better for slow, technical hikes than speed.
Pros
- High shaft for excellent ankle support
- Durable pigskin leather and mesh upper
- Lace-up closure for secure fit
Cons
- Heavy at 48.96 oz
- Not waterproof
- May be overbuilt for moderate trails
Full specifications (5)
- shaft_height
- high
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
- weight
- 48.96 oz
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Fast and light hiking with orthotic support
The OrthoComfoot Women's Orthopedic Hiking Boots is designed for women with orthopedic needs who want to move quickly. It has a roomy wide toe box, a supportive arch insole, and a breathable PU and mesh upper. Despite its high shaft, the boot is built for fast-and-light use. The rubber outsole provides traction on varied terrain. The removable insole is a key plus for custom orthotics.
Pros
- Breathable design
- Wide toe box for orthotics
- Arch support included
Cons
- High shaft may feel restrictive for some
- Weight not specified
Full specifications (5)
- shaft_height
- high
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
- breathable
- Yes
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Backpacking with waterproof needs
The Merrell Moab 3 RXZER23 is a mid-height waterproof hiking boot from Merrell, reinforced with a protective toe cap. It is built for backpacking with heavy loads, offering a waterproof membrane and a rubber outsole for traction. The lace-up closure and bellows tongue keep debris out. The removable insole works well with custom orthotics. On paper, it is a durable choice for multi-day trips.
Pros
- Waterproof protection
- Mid shaft for good ankle support
- Bellows tongue keeps out debris
Cons
- Weight not specified but likely heavier
- Not breathable
Full specifications (5)
- waterproof
- Yes
- shaft_height
- mid
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Easy-access waterproof hiking with orthotics
The Orthofeet Carmel from Orthofeet is a high-shaft waterproof leather boot with a hands-free slip-on entry. This design eliminates the need to tie laces, making it easy to put on and take off. The rubber outsole and waterproof leather keep feet dry in wet conditions. It is suitable for backpacking trips where convenience and waterproofing matter. The removable insole can accommodate custom orthotics.
Pros
- Hands-free slip-on entry
- Waterproof leather
- High shaft for ankle support
Cons
- Weight not specified
- No breathability data
- Slip-on may lack secure fit
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- shaft_height
- high
- upper_material
- leather
- outsole_material
- rubber
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Barefoot-style fast hiking with orthotics
The OrthoComfoot Men's Orthopedic Wide Barefoot Shoes takes a zero-drop, barefoot approach while adding orthopedic arch support and a wide toe box. Its breathable mesh upper and EVA outsole keep weight down. The lace-up closure allows a customized fit. This shoe is best for fast-and-light hiking when you want ground feel and natural foot movement. The removable insole is compatible with custom orthotics.
Pros
- Zero-drop platform for natural movement
- Breathable mesh upper
- Wide toe box
Cons
- No waterproofing
- No ankle support
- EVA outsole may wear faster on sharp rocks
Full specifications (4)
- upper_material
- mesh
- outsole_material
- eva
- breathable
- Yes
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Waterproof backpacking with orthopedic support
The OrthoComfoot Men's Orthopedic Wide Waterproof Hiking Boots is a mid-height waterproof boot from OrthoComfoot with a combination upper and rubber outsole. It is built for men who need orthopedic support and waterproof protection on wet trails. The wide toe box and removable arch support insole accommodate custom orthotics. This boot suits backpacking in damp conditions. The scratch-resistant shell protects the toes.
Pros
- Waterproof and scratch-resistant
- Mid shaft for ankle support
- Wide toe box for orthotics
Cons
- Weight not specified
- No breathability data
- Lace type not specified
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- shaft_height
- mid
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Fast and light in variable weather
The Orthofeet Alma is a waterproof and breathable hiking shoe from Orthofeet. It has a rubber outsole with deep lugs for traction and a lace-up closure. Its combination of waterproof protection and breathability makes it a versatile option for fast-and-light hikes where weather is unpredictable. The removable insole works with custom orthotics. It is a solid choice for hikers who want both water resistance and ventilation.
Pros
- Waterproof and breathable
- Deep lug outsole
- Lace-up closure
Cons
- Shaft height not listed
- Weight not specified
- Upper material not specified
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- outsole_material
- rubber
- breathable
- Yes
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: All-day comfort on moderate trails
The OrthoComfoot Orthopedic Wide Waterproof Hiking Boots is a high-shaft waterproof boot with a synthetic upper and rubber outsole. It features a wide fit and orthotic arch support to reduce foot fatigue. The lace-up closure allows fine-tuning of the fit. This boot is built for all-day comfort on moderate trails. Its high shaft provides good ankle support, and the removable insole can hold custom orthotics.
Pros
- High shaft for ankle support
- Waterproof
- Arch support included
Cons
- Weight not specified
- Synthetic upper may not breathe well
- No breathability data
Full specifications (5)
- waterproof
- Yes
- shaft_height
- high
- upper_material
- synthetic
- outsole_material
- rubber
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Fast and light trail running with orthotics
The OrthoComfoot Women's Wide Orthopedic Trail Running Shoes is a women's trail running shoe with a wide toe box and breathable mesh upper. It is designed for fast-and-light hiking and trail running. The rubber outsole provides traction, and the breathable mesh keeps feet cool. The removable orthotic insole can accommodate custom orthotics. With no shaft height, it offers agility but minimal ankle support.
Pros
- Breathable mesh
- Wide toe box
- Trail running compatibility
Cons
- No waterproofing
- No ankle support
- Closure type not specified
Full specifications (3)
- upper_material
- mesh
- outsole_material
- rubber
- breathable
- Yes
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Plantar fasciitis relief on fast hikes
The OrthoComfoot Men's Wide Orthopedic Plantar Fasciitis Shoes is designed for men who need relief from plantar fasciitis on the trail. It has a combination upper, breathable mesh, and a rubber outsole. The wide toe box and contoured orthotic insole offer support for flat feet and overpronation. This shoe is suitable for fast-and-light hikes where foot comfort is a priority. The removable insole works with custom orthotics.
Pros
- Targeted arch support
- Breathable
- Wide toe box
Cons
- No waterproofing
- No shaft height listed
- Weight not specified
Full specifications (3)
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
- breathable
- Yes
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Warm-weather fast hiking with orthotics
The OrthoComfoot Men's Orthopedic Wide Trail Running Shoes is a men's trail running shoe with a leather and mesh upper and an EVA outsole. It offers a wide toe box and reinforced arch support. The breathable construction suits warm-weather fast-and-light hiking. The removable insole can be replaced with custom orthotics. This shoe prioritizes comfort and natural foot movement over protection.
Pros
- Breathable and lightweight
- Wide toe box
- Arch support
Cons
- EVA outsole may lack durability on rough terrain
- No waterproofing
- No ankle support
Full specifications (3)
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- eva
- breathable
- Yes
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Wet-weather day hikes with orthotics
The Orthofeet Avalon 614415044964 is a men's waterproof hiking shoe from Orthofeet with a synthetic upper and rubber outsole. It includes arch support and a lace-up closure for a secure fit. The waterproof protection makes it a reliable choice for wet trails. The removable insole accommodates custom orthotics. This shoe is best for day hikes in damp conditions where ankle support is less critical.
Pros
- Waterproof
- Arch support
- Lace-up closure
Cons
- Shaft height not specified
- Weight not listed
- No breathability data
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- upper_material
- synthetic
- outsole_material
- rubber
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
How to choose
Make sure the insole comes out
The most important feature for custom orthotics is a removable insole. Many hiking shoes have glued-in footbeds that cannot be swapped. Look for models that explicitly state a removable contoured insole. The Columbia Crestwood 178118, Merrell Moab 3 J035896, and most OrthoComfoot models have this feature. Without it, your custom orthotics will not fit properly. The thickness of the insole also matters: if the stock insole is thick, there may be less volume for your orthotic. A shoe with a wide toe box gives extra room for inserts.
Choose the right height for your load
Shaft height affects ankle support and how well the shoe works with orthotics. Low shafts offer freedom of movement but less lateral support. Mid shafts strike a balance for most day hikes. High shafts, like those on the Merrell Moab 3 J035896 or Orthofeet Carmel, provide maximum stability for backpacking with heavy packs. However, some high-shaft boots may be stiff and require break-in. Consider your load and trail difficulty. See our guide to best full boot hiking boots for more on high-shaft models.
Decide between dry feet and cool feet
Waterproof hiking shoes keep your feet dry in rain and puddles, but they often sacrifice breathability. If you hike in warm weather or on dry trails, a breathable shoe like the Columbia Crestwood 178118 or OrthoComfoot Women's Orthopedic Hiking Boots may be more comfortable. If you encounter wet conditions frequently, a waterproof model like the Merrell Moab 3 RXZER23 or Orthofeet Alma is better. Note that waterproof shoes can trap heat and moisture, which may cause blisters with orthotics. Compare options in our best goretex waterproof hiking boots.
Balance weight with durability
Weight matters more when you carry extra gear or cover long distances. The Columbia Crestwood 178118 is the lightest at 20 oz, making it ideal for fast hikes. Heavier boots like the Merrell Moab 3 J035896 offer robust construction but add fatigue. The outsole material also affects grip: rubber outsoles generally provide better traction on rock and gravel than EVA. Most hiking shoes in this comparison use rubber, but models with EVA outsoles (OrthoComfoot Men's Orthopedic Wide Barefoot Shoes, OrthoComfoot Men's Orthopedic Wide Trail Running Shoes) are lighter and more cushioned. For more on outsole traction, see our best grip hiking shoes womens guide.
How you secure the shoe matters
Lace-up closures let you tighten different zones for a perfect fit around the orthotic and the ankle. Some shoes, like the Orthofeet Carmel, use a slip-on entry that eliminates laces entirely. While convenient, slip-on designs may not offer the same snugness. A secure closure prevents heel slip, which is crucial when you add an orthotic that changes the volume of the shoe. For more tips, check out our guide to best fit for hiking boots.
Frequently asked questions
Will my custom orthotics fit in any of these hiking shoes?
Most of the hiking shoes we compared have a removable insole, which is necessary for custom orthotics. Look for models like the Columbia Crestwood 178118 or OrthoComfoot Women's Orthopedic Hiking Boots that specifically mention a removable footbed. You should also check the shoe's volume: a wide toe box helps accommodate thicker orthotics. If you prefer a flat sole, our best flat soled hiking boots guide covers that style.
What shaft height is best for hiking with orthotics?
It depends on your activity. Low and mid shafts are good for day hikes and fast paces. High shafts offer more ankle support, which can help if your orthotics correct for instability. Our picks include all three heights, so choose based on your load and terrain.
Are waterproof hiking shoes less breathable?
Yes, generally waterproof membranes reduce airflow compared to non-waterproof shoes. If you hike in warm weather, a breathable shoe may be more comfortable. Some models, like the Orthofeet Alma, aim to balance both features. Consider your typical climate when choosing.
How do I know if a shoe is wide enough for my custom orthotics?
Look for shoes with a 'wide toe box' or 'wide fit' in the description. Many OrthoComfoot models are designed with extra width. You can also remove the stock insole and place your orthotic inside the shoe to check fit before buying.
Can I use custom orthotics with slip-on hiking shoes?
Yes, as long as the insole is removable. The Orthofeet Carmel is a slip-on boot with a removable insole. However, the fit may be less adjustable than lace-up shoes, so check the fit carefully with your orthotics.
Bottom line
The Columbia Crestwood 178118 is our top pick for day hikers who want a lightweight shoe that works with custom orthotics. For fast-and-light adventures, the OrthoComfoot Women's Orthopedic Hiking Boots offers support without excess weight. Backpackers facing wet conditions should consider the Merrell Moab 3 RXZER23 for its waterproof build. If you prioritize ease of entry, the Orthofeet Carmel slip-on boot is a convenient option. The remaining models fill niches for specific foot needs and trails.