Quick answer
After comparing specifications, the Danner Mountain 600 4.5"-M is our top pick for its light weight and waterproof leather build. For fast and light hiking, the Columbia Crestwood 178118 offers breathability and a low weight. Both are popular on Reddit for different needs.
Our top picks
Best overall
Danner Mountain 600 4.5"-M
All-day hiking and backpacking on wet trails
Best for fast and light
Columbia Crestwood 178118
Fast and light hiking on dry trails
Best for day hiking
KEEN Targhee 4 1028987
Day hiking on moderate, wet trails
#4 pick
Columbia Fairbanks Mid Hiking Boots
Day hiking in wet conditions
#5 pick
Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II 1594732
Fast and light hiking on mixed terrain
#6 pick
Columbia Transverse Hike 207780
Women's fast and light hiking
#7 pick
Columbia Crestwood Mid 2100641
Fast and light day hikes
#8 pick
NORTIV 8 Men's Ankle High Waterproof Hiking Boots
Casual hiking and quick walks
#9 pick
Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II 174641
Rugged trails and wet weather
#10 pick
Timberland White Ledge Mid TB012135214
Extended hikes in wet conditions
#11 pick
Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped 1718822
Women's waterproof hiking
#12 pick
NORTIV8 Men's Waterproof Lightweight Hiking Boots Js19005m
Hikers with wide feet on a budget
#13 pick
Timberland Mt. Maddsen TB02730R242
Short, heavy-duty hikes requiring maximum protection
On this page
This guide is for anyone browsing Reddit for hiking boot recommendations. We compared the published specifications of 13 popular models to find which ones suit day hiking, fast-and-light trips, and wet trails. Our picks are based solely on specs like waterproofing, weight, upper material, and breathability. For more on waterproof options, check our guide to best Gore-Tex waterproof hiking boots. Whether you need ankle support or a lightweight shoe, this comparison helps you choose.
Comparison at a glance
Key specs · full specs in each pick| Model | waterproof | shaft_height | upper_material | outsole_material | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
Yes | - | leather | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
- | - | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | mid | - | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | mid | - | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | low | combination | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | leather | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | leather | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | leather | rubber | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | combination | - | View on Amazon |
|
|
Yes | - | leather | rubber | View on Amazon |
Best for: All-day hiking and backpacking on wet trails
The Danner Mountain 600 4.5"-M is a men's waterproof hiking boot with a leather upper and a waterproof membrane. It weighs 19.2 oz, making it the lightest boot in our comparison. The rubber outsole provides traction on varied terrain. On paper, this boot balances low weight with full waterproofing, which suits hikers who want comfort without sacrificing protection. Compared to heavier options like the Timberland Mt. Maddsen TB02730R242, it is much lighter.
Pros
- Lightest weight in comparison
- Waterproof leather and Danner Dry barrier
- Vibram rubber outsole for grip
Cons
- Breathability not specified
- Lace-up closure requires adjustment
Full specifications (5)
- waterproof
- Yes
- upper_material
- leather
- outsole_material
- rubber
- weight
- 19.2 oz
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Fast and light hiking on dry trails
The Columbia Crestwood 178118 is a men's lightweight hiking boot designed for fast-and-light trips. It weighs 20 oz and features a combination upper that is Yes. The rubber outsole offers reliable grip. It lacks a waterproof rating from the manufacturer, making it best for dry conditions. Compared to the Danner Mountain 600 4.5"-M, it trades waterproofing for lighter weight and breathability.
Pros
- Breathable suede mesh for ventilation
- Lightweight design
- Rubber outsole provides solid traction
Cons
- Not listed as waterproof
- Combination upper may be less durable than leather
Full specifications (4)
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
- weight
- 20 oz
- breathable
- Yes
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Day hiking on moderate, wet trails
The KEEN Targhee 4 1028987 is a men's mid-height waterproof hiking boot from KEEN. It has a rubber outsole, a Yes membrane, and a lace-up closure. The boot is designed for day hiking with a waterproof KEEN.DRY barrier. While its weight is not specified by the manufacturer, its mid shaft provides additional ankle support. It fits the day-hiking use case well with its balance of waterproofing and breathability.
Pros
- Waterproof KEEN.DRY membrane
- Breathable mesh lining
- Mid shaft for ankle support
Cons
- Weight not specified
- Combination upper may collect debris
Full specifications (5)
- waterproof
- Yes
- shaft_height
- mid
- outsole_material
- rubber
- breathable
- Yes
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Day hiking in wet conditions
The Columbia Fairbanks Mid Hiking Boots is a men's waterproof mid-height hiking boot from Columbia. It features a rubber outsole and is Yes. The upper material is not listed by the manufacturer, but the boot includes Omni-Tech waterproofing. It is suitable for day hiking and fast-and-light trips due to its balanced specs. Its weight is not provided, so consider it against lighter options.
Pros
- Omni-Tech waterproof construction
- Breathable fabric
- Mid height supports ankle
Cons
- Upper material not specified
- Weight not specified
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- shaft_height
- mid
- outsole_material
- rubber
- breathable
- Yes
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Fast and light hiking on mixed terrain
The Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II 1594732 is a men's waterproof hiking boot with a combination upper and a rubber outsole. It is Yes and uses a lace-up closure. The boot is designed for fast-and-light hiking with its combination of leather and mesh. Its weight is not listed, but the Techlite midsole offers cushioning. It is a versatile option for varied trails.
Pros
- Waterproof and breathable
- Combination upper balances durability and flexibility
- Lace-up closure for snug fit
Cons
- Weight not specified
- May run narrow for wide feet
Full specifications (5)
- waterproof
- Yes
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
- breathable
- Yes
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Women's fast and light hiking
The Columbia Transverse Hike 207780 is a women's waterproof hiking boot with a combination upper, rubber outsole, and Yes construction. It is designed for fast-and-light hiking with Omni-Tech waterproofing. The boot offers a women-specific fit. Its weight and shaft height are not provided, but it combines waterproofing and breathability for moderate hikes.
Pros
- Waterproof and breathable
- Women's specific fit
- Omni-Tech protection
Cons
- Weight not specified
- Shaft height not specified
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
- breathable
- Yes
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Fast and light day hikes
The Columbia Crestwood Mid 2100641 is a men's waterproof mid-height boot from Columbia. It has a combination upper, rubber outsole, and is Yes. The Omni-Tech waterproof lining keeps feet dry. It is suited for fast-and-light day hikes. Weight and shaft height are not listed, but the boot's combination upper offers a balance of durability and weight.
Pros
- Omni-Tech waterproof membrane
- Breathable for active hiking
- Combination upper for durability
Cons
- Weight not specified
- Upper material blend may limit longevity
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
- breathable
- Yes
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Casual hiking and quick walks
The NORTIV 8 Men's Ankle High Waterproof Hiking Boots is a men's ankle-high waterproof boot with a combination upper and a rubber outsole. It has a low shaft height, offering flexibility over support. EVA midsoles provide cushioning. The boot is affordable but lacks a breathability spec. It is best for casual hiking and dry conditions.
Pros
- Waterproof construction
- Low cut for flexibility
- EVA midsole for comfort
Cons
- Low shaft offers less ankle support
- Breathability not specified
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- shaft_height
- low
- upper_material
- combination
- outsole_material
- rubber
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Rugged trails and wet weather
The Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II 174641 is a men's waterproof hiking boot with a leather upper and a rubber outsole. It uses a lace-up closure. The boot is built for durability with full leather construction. Its weight is not provided, but it is likely heavier than mesh boots. It is suitable for rugged trails and wet conditions.
Pros
- Waterproof leather upper
- Durable construction
- Lace-up closure for secure fit
Cons
- Weight not specified
- May lack breathability
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- upper_material
- leather
- outsole_material
- rubber
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Extended hikes in wet conditions
The Timberland White Ledge Mid TB012135214 is a men's waterproof hiking boot with a leather upper and a rubber outsole. It features speed-lace hardware for quick adjustments. The boot offers robust waterproofing from Timberland. Its weight is not provided, but full-grain leather adds durability. It is best for extended hikes in wet conditions.
Pros
- Waterproof premium Timberland leather
- Speed-lace hardware for easy use
- Rubber outsole for traction
Cons
- Weight not specified
- May be heavy due to leather
Full specifications (4)
- waterproof
- Yes
- upper_material
- leather
- outsole_material
- rubber
- closure_type
- speed-lace
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Women's waterproof hiking
The Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped 1718822 is a women's waterproof hiking boot with a leather upper and a rubber outsole. It is designed for durability with full leather construction. Many specs like weight, breathability, and closure are not listed. It is best for hikers prioritizing waterproofing over weight.
Pros
- Waterproof leather upper
- Women's specific fit
Cons
- Multiple specs not provided
- Likely heavy due to full leather
Full specifications (3)
- waterproof
- Yes
- upper_material
- leather
- outsole_material
- rubber
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Hikers with wide feet on a budget
The NORTIV8 Men's Waterproof Lightweight Hiking Boots Js19005m is a men's waterproof hiking boot with a combination upper. It is designed for wider feet according to the seller. The boot uses suede and faux leather. Many specs like outsole, weight, and breathability are not listed. It is a budget-friendly option for hikers with wide feet.
Pros
- Waterproof suede and membrane
- Wider fit available
- Removable insole for arch support
Cons
- Many specs not listed
- Build quality may be lower than premium brands
Best for: Short, heavy-duty hikes requiring maximum protection
The Timberland Mt. Maddsen TB02730R242 is a men's waterproof hiking boot with a leather upper and a rubber outsole. It weighs 48 oz, making it the heaviest boot in our comparison. The weight provides durability but may fatigue hikers on long routes. It uses a lace-up closure. It is best for short, heavy-duty hikes where maximum protection is needed.
Pros
- Waterproof premium leather
- Rubber outsole for traction
- Durable construction
Cons
- Heavy weight
- Breathability not specified
Full specifications (5)
- waterproof
- Yes
- upper_material
- leather
- outsole_material
- rubber
- weight
- 48 oz
- closure_type
- lace-up
Specs: Amazon listing
How to choose
Waterproofing and Breathability
Waterproof boots keep feet dry in wet conditions, but they can trap moisture and reduce airflow. Breathable membranes like Omni-Tech or KEEN.DRY allow vapor to escape while blocking water. If you hike in rain, snow, or cross streams, look for a model that lists both waterproof and breathable in its specs. For dry, fast hikes, a non-waterproof boot may work better. Consider your typical trail conditions when deciding. For a comparison of Gore-Tex models, see best Gore-Tex waterproof hiking boots.
Weight
Boot weight directly affects how tired your feet feel at the end of a long day. A lighter boot like the Danner Mountain 600 4.5"-M weighs 19.2 oz, reducing fatigue, while heavier boots like the Timberland Mt. Maddsen TB02730R242 weigh 48 oz and add durability but weigh you down. For day hikes or fast-and-light trips, lighter boots are preferable to reduce fatigue. For backpacking with heavy loads, a slightly heavier boot may provide better support. Check the manufacturer's weight spec before buying. For heavy-duty options, see best Grand Canyon hiking boots.
Upper Materials
The upper material affects durability, weight, and breathability. Leather uppers are tough and naturally water-resistant but heavier and less breathable. Mesh uppers are light and airy but less durable and prone to punctures. Combination uppers blend leather and mesh for a balance of both. Think about the terrain: leather suits rocky, abrasive trails, while mesh works better for well-groomed paths. For more on full-grain leather, check best full grain hiking boots.
Shaft Height
Shaft height determines ankle support and flexibility. Low-cut models are light and allow full ankle movement, good for fast hiking on smooth trails. Mid-height boots support the ankle without restricting movement too much, ideal for day hiking on uneven ground. High-cut boots offer maximum stability for carrying heavy packs over rough terrain. Choose based on your pack weight and risk of rolling an ankle. A mid shaft is a versatile choice for most hikers.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best hiking boots for beginners?
Beginners should look for a mid-weight waterproof boot with a combination upper for a good balance of support and comfort. The KEEN Targhee 4 1028987 and Columbia Crestwood 178118 are popular choices. For women starting out, see best female beginner hiking boots.
Are waterproof hiking boots worth it?
Yes, if you hike in wet conditions or near streams. Waterproof boots keep your feet dry but are heavier and less breathable. For dry trails, non-waterproof shoes may be more comfortable. Check the specs to see if the boot also lists breathability to avoid sweaty feet.
How should hiking boots fit?
Leave about a thumb's width of space between your longest toe and the front of the boot. Your heel should not slip. Try boots on with the socks you plan to wear hiking. A snug fit without pressure points is key to avoiding blisters.
What is the difference between hiking boots and hiking shoes?
Hiking boots have higher shafts that support the ankle, offer more protection, and are often heavier. Hiking shoes are lighter, more flexible, and better for fast hiking on easy trails. Choose boots for rough terrain or heavy packs, and shoes for day hikes and light loads.
Bottom line
For the best all-around boot, choose the Danner Mountain 600 4.5"-M for its light weight and waterproof build. Pick the Columbia Crestwood 178118 for fast, dry hikes or the KEEN Targhee 4 1028987 for day trips. For heavy-duty protection, the Timberland Mt. Maddsen TB02730R242 offers unmatched durability. Women may prefer the Columbia Transverse Hike 207780 or Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped 1718822. See best flexible women's hiking boots for more options.