Yeti vs Pelican Coolers

We earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. Learn more.

Quick answer

Our top pick is the Pelican Elite 250QT-2-TAN for extended camping trips, with a massive 250 qt capacity and 10 days of ice retention. For lightweight picnics, the Pelican 14 Quart Cooler offers a portable 14 qt size and a swing-up handle.

Our top picks

On this page
  1. Our top picks
  2. Comparison
  3. 1. 250QT-2-TAN
  4. 2. 14Q-1-DKGRYEGRN
  5. 3. 14Q-1-MBLWHT
  6. 4. 8 Quart Cooler
  7. 5. 8Q-1-DSGGRY
  8. 6. 14Q-16-TANKASBL
  9. 7. 14Q-1-WHTGRY
  10. 8. 14Q-5-OSHAREDWHT
  11. 9. 8Q-1-DKGRYEGRN
  12. 10. Hopper M Series Soft Sided Backpack Cooler
  13. 11. 8Q-15-JUNMTAN
  14. 12. 14Q-1-CMTWHT
  15. 13. FB151GN1
  16. How to choose
  17. FAQ
  18. Bottom line

Choosing between Yeti and Pelican coolers comes down to how you'll use them. In this Yeti vs Pelican cooler comparison, we looked at hard-sided Pelican models ranging from compact personal coolers to a massive 250 qt beast, plus a soft YETI backpack cooler. We compared specifications like capacity, ice retention, weight, and extra features to match each cooler to real-world use cases. Whether you need a lightweight picnic companion or a multi-day ice chest for camping, our picks are based on the numbers and defined scenarios, not guesswork.

Comparison at a glance

Key specs · full specs in each pick
Model capacity_qt weight_lb ice_retention_days can_capacity Link
Pelican Elite 250 Quart Cooler 250QT-2-TAN 250 qt - 10 days - View on Amazon
Pelican 14 Quart Cooler 14Q-1-DKGRYEGRN 14 qt 8.3 lb - - View on Amazon
Pelican 14 Quart Cooler 14Q-1-MBLWHT 14 qt 8.3 lb - - View on Amazon
Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers 8 Quart Cooler 8 qt 5 lb - - View on Amazon
Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers 8Q-1-DSGGRY 8 qt 5 lb - - View on Amazon
Pelican 14 Quart Cooler 14Q-16-TANKASBL 14 qt 8.3 lb - - View on Amazon
Pelican 14 Quart Cooler 14Q-1-WHTGRY 14 qt 8.3 lb - - View on Amazon
Pelican 14 Quart Cooler 14Q-5-OSHAREDWHT 14 qt 8.3 lb - - View on Amazon
Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers 8Q-1-DKGRYEGRN 8 qt 6 lb - - View on Amazon
YETI Hopper M Series Backpack Soft Sided Coolers with MagShield Access Hopper M Series Soft Sided Backpack Cooler - 7.9 lb - - View on Amazon
Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers 8Q-15-JUNMTAN 8 qt 5 lb - - View on Amazon
Pelican 14 Quart Cooler 14Q-1-CMTWHT 14 qt 8.3 lb - - View on Amazon
Ninja FrostVault™ 50qt Hard Cooler with Dry Storage Drawer, Spanish Moss FB151GN1 50 qt 29 lb - 80 cans View on Amazon
Pelican Elite 250 Quart Cooler
Best overall

1. Pelican Elite 250QT-2-TAN

capacity_qt 250 qt ice_retention_days 10 days drain Yes

Best for: Extended camping trips and large groups

The Pelican Elite 250QT-2-TAN is a massive hard cooler built for extended camping trips. With a 250 qt capacity and 10 days of ice retention, it can keep food and drinks cold for over a week. The Yes drain plug makes cleaning easy, and the polyurethane-foam insulation ensures efficient cooling. This is the top choice for large groups or long adventures where you need maximum storage and long-lasting ice.

Pros

  • Huge 250 qt capacity
  • 10-day ice retention
  • Drain plug for easy cleaning
  • Lifetime warranty

Cons

  • No dry storage compartment
  • No cup holders
  • Very heavy (weight not listed, but large size implies significant weight)
Full specifications (4)
capacity_qt
250 qt
ice_retention_days
10 days
drain
Yes
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 14 Quart Cooler
Best for lightweight picnic

2. Pelican 14 Quart Cooler

capacity_qt 14 qt weight_lb 8.3 lb handle_type swing-up

Best for: Picnics and short outings

The Pelican 14 Quart Cooler is a portable hard cooler ideal for picnics and day trips. It holds 14 qt of food and drinks, and the swing-up handle makes it easy to carry. Built-in Yes cup holders and a stainless steel bottle opener add convenience. The polyurethane-foam insulation keeps contents cold, and the plastic shell is durable. At just 8.3 lb, it's light enough to carry to the park or beach.

Pros

  • Lightweight at 8.3 lb
  • Swing-up handle for easy carry
  • Molded cup holders
  • Durable plastic construction

Cons

  • No drain plug
  • Ice retention not specified
  • Small capacity for groups
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
14 qt
weight_lb
8.3 lb
handle_type
swing-up
cup_holders
Yes
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 14 Quart Cooler
#3 pick

3. Pelican 14 Quart Cooler

capacity_qt 14 qt weight_lb 8.3 lb handle_type swing-up

Best for: Day trips where you need dry storage

The Pelican 14 Quart Cooler adds a built-in dry storage compartment with a push-button latch, keeping phones and snacks separate from ice. It shares the same 14 qt capacity, 8.3 lb weight, and swing-up handle. The Yes cup holders and bottle opener are also included.

Pros

  • Dry storage compartment
  • Lightweight
  • Cup holders

Cons

  • No drain plug
  • Ice retention not listed
  • Small capacity
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
14 qt
weight_lb
8.3 lb
handle_type
swing-up
cup_holders
Yes
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers
Lowest weight_lb

4. Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers

capacity_qt 8 qt weight_lb 5 lb insulation_type polyurethane-foam

Best for: Solo day trips and lunch boxes

The Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers is the lightest option at just 5 lb, making it perfect for solo lunches or short hikes. Its 8 qt capacity holds a few cans and snacks, and the integrated ice pack helps maintain temperature. The polyurethane-foam insulation and plastic shell provide durability. A removable inner tray and dry storage compartment in the lid add organization.

Pros

  • Ultra-lightweight at 5 lb
  • Integrated ice pack
  • Dry storage compartment
  • Compact size

Cons

  • Very small capacity
  • No drain plug
  • Ice retention not specified
Full specifications (4)
capacity_qt
8 qt
weight_lb
5 lb
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers
#5 pick

5. Pelican 8 Quart Cooler

capacity_qt 8 qt weight_lb 5 lb insulation_type polyurethane-foam

Best for: Personal use for short outings

The Pelican 8 Quart Cooler offers the same 8 qt capacity and 5 lb weight, with an integrated ice pack and dry storage. It's a simple, no-frills personal cooler for keeping a few drinks cold all day.

Pros

  • Lightweight
  • Integrated ice pack
  • Dry storage

Cons

  • Small capacity
  • No drain plug
  • Ice retention not specified
Full specifications (4)
capacity_qt
8 qt
weight_lb
5 lb
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 14 Quart Cooler
#6 pick

6. Pelican 14 Quart Cooler

capacity_qt 14 qt weight_lb 8.3 lb handle_type swing-up

Best for: Casual picnics

The Pelican 14 Quart Cooler is a straightforward 14 qt cooler with Yes cup holders, a swing-up handle, and a durable plastic body. It weighs 8.3 lb and includes a removable tray for non-perishables.

Pros

  • Cup holders
  • Lightweight
  • Swing-up handle

Cons

  • No dry storage compartment
  • No drain plug
  • Ice retention not listed
Full specifications (5)
capacity_qt
14 qt
weight_lb
8.3 lb
handle_type
swing-up
cup_holders
Yes
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 14 Quart Cooler
#7 pick

7. Pelican 14 Quart Cooler

capacity_qt 14 qt weight_lb 8.3 lb handle_type swing-up

Best for: Tailgating and entertainment

The Pelican 14 Quart Cooler stands out with a dry storage compartment that includes a tablet and phone easel slot, making it great for tailgating or beach days. It has the same 14 qt capacity, 8.3 lb weight, and swing-up handle.

Pros

  • Dry storage with device easel
  • Cup holders
  • Lightweight

Cons

  • No drain plug
  • Ice retention not specified
  • Small capacity
Full specifications (5)
capacity_qt
14 qt
weight_lb
8.3 lb
handle_type
swing-up
cup_holders
Yes
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 14 Quart Cooler
#8 pick

8. Pelican 14Q-5-OSHAREDWHT

capacity_qt 14 qt weight_lb 8.3 lb handle_type swing-up

Best for: Basic picnic needs

The Pelican 14Q-5-OSHAREDWHT is a reliable 14 qt cooler with Yes cup holders, a swing-up handle, and a plastic shell. It weighs 8.3 lb and includes a removable tray.

Pros

  • Cup holders
  • Lightweight
  • Swing-up handle

Cons

  • No dry storage
  • No drain plug
  • Ice retention not listed
Full specifications (5)
capacity_qt
14 qt
weight_lb
8.3 lb
handle_type
swing-up
cup_holders
Yes
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers
#9 pick

9. Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers

capacity_qt 8 qt weight_lb 6 lb insulation_type polyurethane-foam

Best for: Lunch boxes and short trips

The Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers is a compact 8 qt cooler with a built-in ice pack. At 6 lb, it's slightly heavier than other 8-quart models but still portable. The polyurethane-foam insulation helps maintain temperature.

Pros

  • Built-in ice pack
  • Compact
  • Durable plastic

Cons

  • Small capacity
  • No dry storage
  • No drain plug
Full specifications (4)
capacity_qt
8 qt
weight_lb
6 lb
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

YETI Hopper M Series Backpack Soft Sided Coolers with MagShield Access
#10 pick

10. YETI Hopper M Series Soft Sided Backpack Cooler

weight_lb 7.9 lb material other

Best for: Hiking and festivals

The YETI Hopper M Series Soft Sided Backpack Cooler is a soft-sided backpack cooler designed for hands-free carry. It features a other shell that resists punctures and UV rays, and a magnetic closure for easy access. At 7.9 lb, it's light enough for hiking. While it lacks the hard-shell durability and ice retention specs of Pelican's rotomolded coolers, its backpack design makes it ideal for day hikes and festivals.

Pros

  • Hands-free backpack carry
  • Durable fabric shell
  • Magnetic leak-resistant closure

Cons

  • No capacity or ice retention specs listed
  • Soft-sided may not insulate as long
  • No cup holders or drain
Full specifications (2)
weight_lb
7.9 lb
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers
#11 pick

11. Pelican 8 Quart Cooler

capacity_qt 8 qt weight_lb 5 lb material plastic

Best for: Minimalist day trips

The Pelican 8 Quart Cooler is a lightweight 8 qt option with an integrated ice pack and dry storage. It weighs just 5 lb and is made of durable plastic.

Pros

  • Ultra-lightweight
  • Integrated ice pack
  • Dry storage

Cons

  • Small capacity
  • No drain plug
  • Ice retention not specified
Full specifications (3)
capacity_qt
8 qt
weight_lb
5 lb
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican 14 Quart Cooler
#12 pick

12. Pelican 14 Quart Cooler 14Q-1-CMTWHT

capacity_qt 14 qt weight_lb 8.3 lb handle_type swing-up

Best for: Simple picnics

The Pelican 14 Quart Cooler 14Q-1-CMTWHT is a 14 qt cooler with a swing-up handle and Yes cup holders. It weighs 8.3 lb and includes a removable tray. While insulation type isn't specified, it's built with Pelican's typical durability.

Pros

  • Cup holders
  • Lightweight
  • Swing-up handle

Cons

  • Insulation type not listed
  • No dry storage
  • No drain plug
Full specifications (4)
capacity_qt
14 qt
weight_lb
8.3 lb
handle_type
swing-up
cup_holders
Yes

Specs: Amazon listing

Ninja FrostVault™ 50qt Hard Cooler with Dry Storage Drawer, Spanish Moss
#13 pick

13. Ninja FrostVault FB151GN1

capacity_qt 50 qt weight_lb 29 lb can_capacity 80 cans

Best for: Family camping and tailgating

The Ninja FrostVault FB151GN1 is a 50 qt hard cooler with a unique dry storage drawer that keeps food cool and separate from drinks. It holds up to 80 cans without ice, and the plastic construction is heavy-duty. At 29 lb, it's the heaviest option here, but the dry drawer and large capacity make it great for tailgating or family camping where organization matters.

Pros

  • Dry storage drawer keeps food separate
  • Large 50 qt capacity
  • Holds up to 80 cans

Cons

  • Heavy at 29 lb
  • Ice retention not specified
  • No cup holders or drain
Full specifications (4)
capacity_qt
50 qt
weight_lb
29 lb
can_capacity
80 cans
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

How to choose

Capacity: How much space do you need?

The right capacity depends on your group size and trip length. For solo day trips, an 8 qt cooler like the Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers holds a few cans and snacks. A 14 qt model suits two people for a picnic. For a weekend with friends, a 50 qt cooler such as the Ninja FrostVault FB151GN1 offers plenty of space. And for extended camping trips, the Pelican Elite 250QT-2-TAN provides a massive 250 qt. Consider how many cans you need to chill; some models list can capacity, like the Ninja's 80 cans. If you often host large groups, check out our guide to large-capacity coolers.

Ice retention: How long should it stay cold?

Ice retention is crucial for multi-day trips. The Pelican Elite 250QT-2-TAN claims up to 10 days of ice retention thanks to its polyurethane-foam insulation and freezer-grade gasket. Smaller Pelican coolers don't list specific ice retention times, but their polyurethane foam insulation still provides solid cooling for day trips. For the best ice retention in a rotomolded design, see our rotomolded cooler picks.

Weight and portability: Carrying comfort matters

If you'll be carrying your cooler far from the car, weight matters. The lightest options are the 8 qt Pelican models at just 5 lb. The 14 qt coolers weigh around 8.3 lb, still manageable for short walks. The YETI Hopper M Series Soft Sided Backpack Cooler backpack cooler distributes weight on your shoulders, making it comfortable for hikes. On the other end, the Ninja FrostVault FB151GN1 weighs 29 lb, so it's best for car camping or tailgating. For even more portable designs, check out our collapsible cooler recommendations.

Extra features: Drain plugs, cup holders, and dry storage

Beyond cooling, features like drain plugs, cup holders, and dry storage can make a big difference. The Pelican Elite 250QT-2-TAN includes a Yes drain plug for easy cleaning. Many 14 qt Pelicans have Yes cup holders and a bottle opener. Some models, like the Pelican 14 Quart Cooler, add a dry storage compartment for phones and keys. The Ninja FrostVault FB151GN1 takes it further with a full dry drawer that keeps food separate from ice. If you prefer a cooler without zippers, see our zipperless cooler picks.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between Yeti and Pelican coolers?

Pelican specializes in hard-sided coolers with thick insulation and large capacities, like the Pelican Elite 250QT-2-TAN. YETI offers a range of hard and soft coolers; the YETI Hopper M Series Soft Sided Backpack Cooler is a soft backpack cooler with a magnetic closure and durable fabric. Choose Pelican for maximum ice retention and capacity, or YETI for a portable, hands-free design.

How long does ice last in a Pelican cooler?

The Pelican Elite 250QT-2-TAN is rated for up to 10 days of ice retention. Smaller Pelican coolers don't list specific ice retention times, but their polyurethane foam insulation provides all-day cooling for typical outings.

What size Pelican cooler is best for a day trip?

For one or two people, a 14-quart cooler like the Pelican 14 Quart Cooler offers enough space for lunch and drinks without being too heavy. If you're packing light, an 8-quart model such as the Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers is even more portable.

Do Pelican coolers come with a warranty?

Yes, many Pelican coolers include a lifetime guarantee that covers breakage. Some smaller models come with a 3-year guarantee. Check the product details for specifics.

Bottom line

For extended camping trips, the Pelican Elite 250QT-2-TAN is the clear winner with its massive capacity and long ice retention. If you need a lightweight cooler for picnics, any of the 14 qt Pelicans will serve you well, especially the Pelican 14 Quart Cooler with its dry storage. Solo adventurers will appreciate the ultralight Pelican 8 Quart Personal Lunch Box Coolers. The YETI Hopper M Series Soft Sided Backpack Cooler is the best choice for hands-free hiking, and the Ninja FrostVault FB151GN1 offers unique dry storage for organized family outings. For more cooling options, see our iceless cooler guide.