Quick answer
The Igloo Polar-Igloo is our top pick for most people, thanks to its massive 120 qt capacity and wheeled design that makes it easy to move. For longer ice retention, the RTIC 22 QT Ultra-Light Cooler holds ice for 6 days.
Our top picks
Best overall
Igloo Polar-Igloo
Large group tailgates and rough terrain
Best for large group tailgate
Igloo Maxcold Glide Pro
Large group tailgates
#3 pick
Igloo Marine Cooler 50297
Short trips and solo outings
#4 pick
Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler
Tailgates and day trips
Top ice_retention_days
RTIC 22 QT Ultra-Light Cooler
Extended trips and solo camping
Best for lightweight picnic
Coleman Chiller Cooler 2228695
Lightweight picnics and extra seating
#7 pick
Igloo BMX 52
Camping and rugged use
#8 pick
Igloo Trailmate Journey 70 Qt
Large groups on rough terrain
#9 pick
Igloo Trailmate Trail Mate
Day trips and beach outings
#10 pick
Igloo Classic Playmate Elite
Quick picnics and lunches
#11 pick
RTIC Ultra-Light 13046
Camping and tailgating
#12 pick
RTIC Road Trip Cooler 29127
Road trips and tight spaces
#13 pick
RTIC Ultra-Light 30822
Weekend camping and extended trips
On this page
Choosing between an RTIC and an Igloo cooler means balancing capacity, portability, and ice retention. This guide compares models from both brands, plus a standout Coleman, to help you find the right cooler for tailgates, camping, or picnics. We based our picks on manufacturer specifications and how each cooler fits common outdoor scenarios. If you’re looking for a rotomolded-style cooler but want something lighter, check out our rotomolded cooler alternatives.
Comparison at a glance
Key specs · full specs in each pick| Model | capacity_qt | weight_lb | ice_retention_days | can_capacity | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
120 qt | - | - | 188 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
110 qt | 25.4 lb | - | 168 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
54 qt | 5 lb | - | 85 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
52 qt | 19.9 lb | - | 80 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
22 qt | 11.7 lb | 6 days | 30 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
16 qt | 3.6 lb | 1.5 days | 25 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
52 qt | 16.4 lb | - | 83 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
70 qt | 35.8 lb | - | 112 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
25 qt | 10.8 lb | - | 38 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
16 qt | 4.2 lb | - | 30 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
52 qt | 21 lb | - | 76 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
16 qt | 6 lb | - | 20 cans | View on Amazon |
|
|
32 qt | - | 5 days | 48 cans | View on Amazon |
Best for: Large group tailgates and rough terrain
The Igloo Polar-Igloo is the biggest cooler in this comparison, with a 120 qt capacity that holds 188 cans. Its wheeled design and swing-up handles make it manageable despite its size, and the drain plug simplifies cleanup. It’s built for large group tailgates and can handle rough terrain, though the manufacturer doesn’t list its weight or ice retention. If you need maximum space and don’t mind the bulk, this is the best overall pick.
Pros
- Largest capacity at 120 qt
- Wheeled for easy mobility
- Swing-up handles and drain plug
Cons
- Weight not disclosed
- No cup holders
- Ice retention not listed
Full specifications (7)
- capacity_qt
- 120 qt
- can_capacity
- 188 cans
- wheeled
- Yes
- handle_type
- swing-up
- drain
- Yes
- insulation_type
- polyethylene
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Large group tailgates
The Igloo Maxcold Glide Pro is a wheeled cooler with a 110 qt capacity and a listed weight of 25.4 lb, making it one of the lighter large-capacity options. It holds 168 cans and includes a drain for easy cleaning. While it lacks a published ice retention figure, its THERMECOOL insulation and UV inhibitors suggest solid performance for day-long tailgates. It’s a strong choice if you want a big cooler that’s still easy to move.
Pros
- 110 qt capacity with wheeled design
- Lightweight for its size at 25.4 lb
- Drain plug included
Cons
- Ice retention not specified
- No cup holders
- Handle type not listed
Full specifications (6)
- capacity_qt
- 110 qt
- weight_lb
- 25.4 lb
- can_capacity
- 168 cans
- wheeled
- Yes
- drain
- Yes
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Short trips and solo outings
The Igloo Marine Cooler 50297 is a compact, lightweight cooler weighing just 5 lb and holding 85 cans. Its metal construction and polyurethane foam insulation provide durability and decent cooling, while the swing-up handles make it easy to carry. It’s not wheeled and lacks a drain, so it’s best for short trips where portability matters more than capacity. Compared to larger Igloo models, it’s a grab-and-go option.
Pros
- Extremely light at 5 lb
- Durable metal body
- Swing-up handles for easy carry
Cons
- No wheels or drain
- Smaller 54 qt capacity
- Ice retention not listed
Full specifications (6)
- capacity_qt
- 54 qt
- weight_lb
- 5 lb
- can_capacity
- 85 cans
- handle_type
- swing-up
- insulation_type
- polyurethane-foam
- material
- metal
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Tailgates and day trips
The Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler is a 52-quart wheeled cooler with a telescoping handle and soft-ride wheels, making it easy to pull over pavement or grass. It holds 80 cans and includes cup holders and a drain. At 19.9 lb, it’s manageable for one person. While ice retention isn’t specified, the extra-thick foam insulation suggests it can keep contents cold for a day. It’s a solid mid-size option for tailgates and picnics.
Pros
- Wheeled with telescoping handle
- Cup holders and drain
- Good 52 qt capacity
Cons
- Ice retention not listed
- Handle type not specified
- No lid weight capacity
Full specifications (8)
- capacity_qt
- 52 qt
- weight_lb
- 19.9 lb
- can_capacity
- 80 cans
- wheeled
- Yes
- cup_holders
- Yes
- drain
- Yes
- insulation_type
- polyurethane-foam
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Extended trips and solo camping
The RTIC 22 QT Ultra-Light Cooler stands out for its 6 days ice retention, the longest in this comparison. Despite its small 22 qt capacity, it holds 30 cans and weighs just 11.7 lb, making it easy to carry. The drain and durable T-latches add convenience. It’s ideal for solo campers or anyone who needs ice to last for days without a bulky cooler. Compared to Igloo’s small models, it offers superior insulation.
Pros
- 6-day ice retention
- Lightweight at 11.7 lb
- Drain and secure latches
Cons
- Small 22 qt capacity
- No wheels or cup holders
- Handle type not specified
Full specifications (7)
- capacity_qt
- 22 qt
- weight_lb
- 11.7 lb
- ice_retention_days
- 6 days
- can_capacity
- 30 cans
- drain
- Yes
- insulation_type
- polyurethane-foam
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Lightweight picnics and extra seating
The Coleman Chiller Cooler 2228695 is the lightest cooler here at 3.6 lb, making it perfect for picnics and short outings. It holds 25 cans and keeps ice for up to 1.5 days. The lid supports 200 lb, so it doubles as a seat. It lacks wheels and a drain, but the bail handle is easy to carry. For a quick trip to the park, it’s hard to beat.
Pros
- Ultra-light 3.6 lb
- Doubles as a seat (200 lb lid)
- Good ice retention for size
Cons
- No wheels or drain
- Small 16 qt capacity
- No cup holders
Full specifications (8)
- capacity_qt
- 16 qt
- weight_lb
- 3.6 lb
- ice_retention_days
- 1.5 days
- can_capacity
- 25 cans
- lid_weight_capacity_lb
- 200 lb
- handle_type
- bail
- insulation_type
- polyurethane-foam
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Camping and rugged use
The Igloo BMX 52 is a rugged 52-quart cooler with blow-molded construction and extra-thick foam insulation. It holds 83 cans and weighs 16.4 lb, making it sturdy but portable. The rubberized T-latches and drain plug add durability. While ice retention isn’t published, the insulation suggests it can handle a weekend trip. It’s a solid choice for camping or tailgating if you don’t need wheels.
Pros
- Durable blow-molded build
- 52 qt capacity with drain
- Lightweight for its toughness
Cons
- No wheels
- Ice retention not listed
- No cup holders
Full specifications (6)
- capacity_qt
- 52 qt
- weight_lb
- 16.4 lb
- can_capacity
- 83 cans
- drain
- Yes
- insulation_type
- other
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Large groups on rough terrain
The Igloo Trailmate Journey 70 Qt is built for serious hauling with 70 qt capacity, 112 cans, and all-terrain wheels. It weighs 35.8 lb, so the telescoping handle and smooth-ride wheels are essential. The polyurethane foam insulation and Cool Riser Technology help maintain temperatures. It’s ideal for beach days or large tailgates where you need to move a lot of drinks over sand or gravel.
Pros
- 70 qt capacity with all-terrain wheels
- Telescoping handle for easy pulling
- Holds 112 cans
Cons
- Heavy at 35.8 lb
- Ice retention not listed
- No drain or cup holders listed
Full specifications (6)
- capacity_qt
- 70 qt
- weight_lb
- 35.8 lb
- can_capacity
- 112 cans
- wheeled
- Yes
- insulation_type
- polyurethane-foam
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Day trips and beach outings
The Igloo Trailmate Trail Mate is a 25-quart cooler with a bail handle, cup holders, and a drain. It weighs 10.8 lb and holds 38 cans. The extra-thick foam insulation and Cool Riser Technology help with cooling, though ice retention isn’t specified. It’s a handy size for a day at the beach or a short hike, offering more features than many small coolers.
Pros
- Cup holders and drain
- Lightweight at 10.8 lb
- Compact 25 qt size
Cons
- No wheels
- Ice retention not listed
- Lid weight capacity unknown
Full specifications (8)
- capacity_qt
- 25 qt
- weight_lb
- 10.8 lb
- can_capacity
- 38 cans
- handle_type
- bail
- cup_holders
- Yes
- drain
- Yes
- insulation_type
- other
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Quick picnics and lunches
The Igloo Classic Playmate Elite is a classic 16-quart cooler with a tent-top lid that swings open from either side. It weighs just 4.2 lb and holds 30 cans. It lacks a drain, wheels, and published ice retention, but its simple design and light weight make it a favorite for quick lunches and picnics. Compared to the Coleman Chiller, it’s slightly heavier but offers a unique lid design.
Pros
- Lightweight at 4.2 lb
- Tent-top lid for easy access
- Holds 30 cans
Cons
- No drain or wheels
- Ice retention not listed
- No cup holders
Full specifications (4)
- capacity_qt
- 16 qt
- weight_lb
- 4.2 lb
- can_capacity
- 30 cans
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Camping and tailgating
The RTIC Ultra-Light 13046 is a 52-quart RTIC cooler that’s lighter than rotomolded models, weighing 21 lb. It holds 76 cans and includes a drain. While ice retention isn’t published, the thick closed-cell foam insulation suggests strong performance. It’s a good alternative to the Igloo BMX 52 if you want a lighter, rotomolded-style cooler without the bulk.
Pros
- Lightweight for a 52 qt cooler
- Durable closed-cell foam insulation
- Drain included
Cons
- Ice retention not listed
- No wheels or cup holders
- Handle type not specified
Full specifications (6)
- capacity_qt
- 52 qt
- weight_lb
- 21 lb
- can_capacity
- 76 cans
- drain
- Yes
- insulation_type
- other
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Road trips and tight spaces
The RTIC Road Trip Cooler 29127 is a slim 16-quart cooler designed to fit in tight spaces like car footwells. It weighs 6 lb and holds 20 cans. The convertible handle and auto-locking lid add convenience. Ice retention isn’t specified, but the polyurethane foam insulation should keep drinks cold for a day trip. It’s a good choice for road trips where space is limited.
Pros
- Slim design fits tight spaces
- Convertible handle/shoulder strap
- Lightweight at 6 lb
Cons
- Small 16 qt capacity
- No drain or wheels
- Ice retention not listed
Full specifications (5)
- capacity_qt
- 16 qt
- weight_lb
- 6 lb
- can_capacity
- 20 cans
- insulation_type
- polyurethane-foam
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
Best for: Weekend camping and extended trips
The RTIC Ultra-Light 30822 offers 5 days ice retention in a mid-size 32 qt package. It holds 48 cans and includes a drain. The weight isn’t published, but the ultra-light construction suggests it’s easy to carry. It’s a strong choice for weekend camping trips where you need ice to last without a huge cooler. Compared to the RTIC 22 QT, it gives you more capacity with nearly the same ice retention.
Pros
- 5-day ice retention
- 32 qt capacity with drain
- Includes dry goods basket and divider
Cons
- Weight not listed
- No wheels or cup holders
- Handle type not specified
Full specifications (6)
- capacity_qt
- 32 qt
- ice_retention_days
- 5 days
- can_capacity
- 48 cans
- drain
- Yes
- insulation_type
- polyurethane-foam
- material
- plastic
Specs: Amazon listing
How to choose
Capacity: How Much Do You Need?
Cooler capacity, measured in quarts, determines how much food and drinks you can pack. For a solo day trip, a small cooler like the Coleman Chiller Cooler 2228695 or Igloo Trailmate Trail Mate is plenty. For a family picnic or small group, a mid-size cooler works well, the RTIC Ultra-Light 30822 and Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler are good examples. Large tailgates or extended camping trips call for a high-capacity cooler; the Igloo Polar-Igloo leads with 120 qt. Think about how many people you’re serving and for how long. If you need even more space, see our guide to larger 150-quart coolers.
Portability: Weight, Wheels, and Handles
A cooler’s weight and how you move it matter as much as its capacity. Lightweight models like the Coleman Chiller Cooler 2228695 at 3.6 lb are easy to carry with a bail handle. Wheeled coolers such as the Igloo Maxcold Glide Pro and Igloo Trailmate Journey 70 Qt let you roll heavy loads over pavement or sand. Check the handle type: telescoping handles offer better leverage, while swing-up handles are simpler. If you often go solo, a compact, lightweight cooler is key. For more portable options, see our best collapsible coolers.
Ice Retention: How Long Will It Stay Cold?
Ice retention tells you how many days a cooler can keep ice frozen under ideal conditions. The RTIC 22 QT Ultra-Light Cooler leads with 6 days, making it great for multi-day trips. The RTIC Ultra-Light 30822 offers 5 days. Many Igloo models don’t publish this spec, so you’ll need to rely on insulation type and user experience. Polyurethane foam generally insulates better than polyethylene. If you need ice to last without electricity, consider a high-retention model. For an alternative that skips ice entirely, check out our best iceless coolers.
Extra Features That Make a Difference
Drains, cup holders, and lid strength can improve your cooler experience. A drain plug makes cleaning and emptying water easy, found on the Igloo Polar-Igloo and RTIC 22 QT Ultra-Light Cooler. Cup holders on the lid, like on the Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler, keep drinks handy. The Coleman Chiller Cooler 2228695 doubles as a seat with a 200 lb lid. Some coolers include bottle openers or cargo nets. Think about which features you’ll actually use. For a different style, see our best zipperless coolers.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, RTIC or Igloo?
It depends on your priorities. RTIC coolers generally offer longer published ice retention, like the RTIC 22 QT Ultra-Light Cooler with 6 days. Igloo offers a wider range of sizes and features, including wheeled models and budget-friendly options. For maximum ice retention, go RTIC; for variety and value, Igloo is strong.
Do RTIC coolers hold ice longer than Igloo?
Based on published specs, yes. The RTIC models we compared list ice retention up to 6 days, while most Igloo coolers don’t publish this figure. However, Igloo’s foam-insulated models can still keep ice for a day or two, which is enough for most outings.
What size cooler do I need for a weekend camping trip?
For a weekend trip with a few people, a mid-size cooler like the RTIC Ultra-Light 30822 or Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler works well. If you’re camping solo, a compact model such as the RTIC 22 QT Ultra-Light Cooler is sufficient. Consider ice retention and whether you’ll need to carry it far.
Can I use a cooler as a seat?
Some coolers are designed to double as a seat. The Coleman Chiller Cooler 2228695 has a reinforced lid that supports 200 lb. Other models may not be rated for sitting, so check the manufacturer’s specs before using a cooler as a chair.
Are there affordable alternatives to RTIC and Igloo?
Yes, brands like Coleman offer budget-friendly coolers. The Coleman Chiller Cooler 2228695 is a great example. For more options, see our best cheap coolers guide.
Bottom line
For most people, the Igloo Polar-Igloo is the best overall cooler with its huge capacity and wheels. If ice retention is your top concern, go with the RTIC 22 QT Ultra-Light Cooler. For lightweight picnics, the Coleman Chiller Cooler 2228695 is hard to beat. Tailgaters will love the Igloo Maxcold Glide Pro or Igloo Trailmate Journey 70 Qt. No matter your adventure, there’s a cooler here that fits.