Pros and Cons of Soft Coolers

We earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. Learn more.

Quick answer

Our top pick is the LARCOOL LA-CO24C, which holds 24 cans and keeps ice for 2 days. It's ideal for day trips and small gatherings. For a lighter, picnic-friendly option, consider the AO Coolers Expedition Original.

Our top picks

On this page
  1. Our top picks
  2. Comparison
  3. 1. LA-CO24C
  4. 2. SW_GreenCanSleeve_10Pk
  5. 3. 21445
  6. 4. Original
  7. How to choose
  8. FAQ
  9. Bottom line

Soft coolers are a versatile choice for camping, picnics, and tailgates, but not all are created equal. This guide breaks down the pros and cons of soft coolers, from capacity and ice retention to weight and durability. We compared four popular models on paper, focusing on specs like can capacity and insulation type, to help you pick the right one for your next outing. We compared each cooler against defined use cases like lightweight picnics and extended camping trips. If you're shopping on a budget, check out our guide to the best cheap cooler.

Comparison at a glance

Key specs ยท full specs in each pick
Model capacity_qt weight_lb ice_retention_days can_capacity Link
Ultra -Tough 24 Can Soft Cooler Bag | Insulated Waterproof Portable Ice Chest with Adjustable Strap | Large Leak-Proof Lunch Coolers Box for Beach | Travel | Camping | Car | Hiking LA-CO24C 19.88 qt 3.09 lb 2 days 24 cans View on Amazon
BeerSkin Silicone Can Covers that Look Like Soda 12 oz (355 ml) - 10 Pk SW_GreenCanSleeve_10Pk - 0.75 lb - - View on Amazon
RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro, Insulated, Waterproof, Leak Proof, Portable Floating Bag for Beverage, Drink, Lunch, Outdoor, Beach, Car, Camping, Picnic, Fishing, Boat 21445 - 4 lb 2 days 20 cans View on Amazon
AO Coolers Expedition Canvas Soft-Sided Cooler Bag, Leak-Proof, Insulated, Lightweight Original 12.68 qt 2 lb - 12 cans View on Amazon
Ultra -Tough 24 Can Soft Cooler Bag | Insulated Waterproof Portable Ice Chest with Adjustable Strap | Large Leak-Proof Lunch Coolers Box for Beach | Travel | Camping | Car | Hiking
Best overall

1. LARCOOL LA-CO24C

capacity_qt 19.88 qt weight_lb 3.09 lb ice_retention_days 2 days

Best for: Day trips and weekend camping

The LARCOOL LA-CO24C is a full-featured soft cooler that balances capacity and portability. With a 24 cans capacity and 2 days of ice retention, it's built for day-long outings and weekend trips. The waterproof, leak-proof design and heavy-duty nylon shell make it durable enough for beach days and camping. At 3.09 lb, it's not the lightest option, but it's still easy to carry with the included shoulder strap. Compared to the RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro, it holds more cans and weighs less, making it our top all-around pick.

Pros

  • Holds 24 cans
  • Keeps ice for 2 days
  • Waterproof and leak-proof
  • Lightweight for its capacity

Cons

  • Not the lightest option
  • No rigid base
  • Insulation material not disclosed
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
19.88 qt
weight_lb
3.09 lb
ice_retention_days
2 days
can_capacity
24 cans
insulation_type
other
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

BeerSkin Silicone Can Covers that Look Like Soda 12 oz (355 ml) - 10 Pk
Lowest weight_lb

2. Skywin BeerSkin SW_GreenCanSleeve_10Pk

weight_lb 0.75 lb material other

Best for: Novelty drink disguise at parties

The Skywin BeerSkin SW_GreenCanSleeve_10Pk is a set of 10 silicone can covers designed to slip over standard cans. At just 0.75 lb, it's the lightest option by a wide margin, but it's not a cooler, it provides no insulation or ice retention. These covers are purely for fun, making your drink look like a soda can. They're reusable and easy to clean, but if you need to keep drinks cold, you'll want a traditional soft cooler like the LARCOOL LA-CO24C or AO Coolers Expedition Original.

Pros

  • Extremely lightweight
  • Fun, discreet design
  • Reusable and easy to clean

Cons

  • No insulation or cooling
  • Not a cooler, no ice retention
  • Only fits standard cans
Full specifications (2)
weight_lb
0.75 lb
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro, Insulated, Waterproof, Leak Proof, Portable Floating Bag for Beverage, Drink, Lunch, Outdoor, Beach, Car, Camping, Picnic, Fishing, Boat
#3 pick

3. RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro

weight_lb 4 lb ice_retention_days 2 days can_capacity 20 cans

Best for: Rugged outdoor adventures and boating

The RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro is built for adventure, with a rugged, puncture-resistant shell and a waterproof, floating design. It holds 20 cans and keeps ice for 2 days thanks to polyurethane-foam insulation. The Cold Lock press lid allows quick access without unzipping, and the waterproof pocket keeps valuables dry. At 4 lb, it's the heaviest in our lineup, but that weight comes with extra durability. If you need a cooler that can handle rough terrain and water, this is a solid choice.

Pros

  • Tough, puncture-resistant build
  • Floats and is fully waterproof
  • 2-day ice retention
  • Convenient press lid

Cons

  • Heaviest option at 4 lb
  • Holds fewer cans than LARCOOL
  • No capacity in quarts listed
Full specifications (5)
weight_lb
4 lb
ice_retention_days
2 days
can_capacity
20 cans
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

AO Coolers Expedition Canvas Soft-Sided Cooler Bag, Leak-Proof, Insulated, Lightweight
Best for lightweight picnic

4. AO Coolers Expedition Original

capacity_qt 12.68 qt weight_lb 2 lb can_capacity 12 cans

Best for: Lightweight picnics and short trips

The AO Coolers Expedition Original is a simple, lightweight soft cooler ideal for picnics and short outings. It holds 12 cans and weighs just 2 lb, making it easy to carry with the shoulder strap. The polyurethane-foam insulation and leak-proof TPU liner provide reliable cooling for a few hours. While it lacks the ice retention specs of the LARCOOL LA-CO24C or RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro, its compact size and low weight make it a great grab-and-go option. For a lightweight picnic cooler, it's hard to beat.

Pros

  • Very lightweight at 2 lb
  • Leak-proof liner
  • Simple, easy to carry
  • Affordable canvas build

Cons

  • Smaller 12-can capacity
  • Ice retention not specified
  • No waterproof pocket
Full specifications (5)
capacity_qt
12.68 qt
weight_lb
2 lb
can_capacity
12 cans
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

How to choose

Capacity: How many cans do you need?

Soft coolers range from small 12-can bags to larger 24-can models. Think about how many people you're packing for and how long you'll be out. The LARCOOL LA-CO24C holds 24 cans, enough for a family picnic, while the AO Coolers Expedition Original is better for solo trips. If you need even more space, check out our best 150 qt cooler guide for high-capacity options.

Ice retention: How long will it stay cold?

Ice retention depends on insulation quality and how you pack the cooler. The LARCOOL LA-CO24C and RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro both promise 2 days of cold storage, making them suitable for weekend trips. The AO Coolers Expedition Original doesn't list ice retention, so it's best for shorter outings. If you want to skip ice entirely, see our best iceless cooler picks.

Weight and portability: Carrying comfort matters

A soft cooler's weight affects how far you'll want to carry it. The Skywin BeerSkin SW_GreenCanSleeve_10Pk is just 0.75 lb, but it's not a cooler. For actual cooling, the AO Coolers Expedition Original at 2 lb is the lightest traditional option, while the RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro is the heaviest at 4 lb. If portability is key, also consider a best collapsible cooler that packs down small.

Durability and design: Built for the outdoors

Soft coolers face bumps, spills, and weather. The RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro stands out with its puncture-resistant fabric and floating, waterproof build. The LARCOOL LA-CO24C offers a leak-proof design and heavy-duty nylon. For the ultimate in ruggedness, a best rotomolded cooler might be worth the extra weight.

Insulation type: What's inside matters

Insulation type affects cooling performance. The RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro and AO Coolers Expedition Original use polyurethane-foam, a dense foam that holds cold well. The LARCOOL LA-CO24C's insulation is listed as 'other,' so its exact performance may vary. A good seal also helps; check out our best zipperless cooler guide for easy-access designs that still prevent leaks.

Frequently asked questions

Are soft coolers as good as hard coolers?

Soft coolers are more portable and lighter, but they typically don't match the ice retention of a high-end rotomolded hard cooler. They're great for day trips and picnics, while hard coolers excel on extended camping trips.

How long do soft coolers keep ice?

It varies by model. The LARCOOL LA-CO24C and RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro claim up to 2 days of ice retention under ideal conditions. Cheaper or smaller coolers may only last a few hours. Pre-chilling the cooler and using block ice can extend performance.

Can I sit on a soft cooler?

Most soft coolers aren't designed to support weight and could collapse or leak. If you need a cooler that doubles as a seat, look for a hard-sided model with a reinforced lid.

Are soft coolers waterproof?

Many soft coolers have waterproof liners and welded seams to prevent leaks. The RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro is fully waterproof and even floats, while the LARCOOL LA-CO24C has a leak-proof design. Always check the specs if you'll be around water.

How do I clean a soft cooler?

Wipe the interior with mild soap and water, and let it air dry completely to prevent mildew. Avoid harsh chemicals that can damage the liner. Some models have removable liners for easier cleaning.

Bottom line

For most people, the LARCOOL LA-CO24C offers the best mix of capacity, ice retention, and portability. If weight is your top concern, the AO Coolers Expedition Original is a great lightweight picnic cooler. The RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler Pro is the go-to for rugged adventures, and the Skywin BeerSkin SW_GreenCanSleeve_10Pk is a fun novelty for parties. No matter your needs, understanding the pros and cons of soft coolers helps you choose the right one.