Igloo Maxcold vs Coleman Xtreme

We earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. Learn more.

Quick answer

The Coleman 316 Series Cooler is our top pick for most campers and tailgaters, with 100 qt of space and 5 days of ice retention. If you need a lighter, more portable option for short outings, consider the Igloo Profile II Series 60402.

Our top picks

On this page
  1. Our top picks
  2. Comparison
  3. 1. 316 Series Cooler
  4. 2. Classic 100qt Desert Sand
  5. 3. 3000005145
  6. 4. 2622044
  7. 5. 44577
  8. 6. 00034572
  9. 7. 34814
  10. 8. 2622043
  11. 9. 00050549
  12. 10. 50303
  13. 11. 34696
  14. 12. Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler
  15. 13. 60402
  16. How to choose
  17. FAQ
  18. Bottom line

Choosing between an Igloo Maxcold and a Coleman Xtreme cooler? We compared the specifications of over a dozen popular wheeled coolers to find the best fit for extended camping trips, tailgates, and picnics. Our picks are based on capacity, ice retention, portability, and extra features like cup holders and drain plugs. Whether you need a massive cooler for a big group or a lightweight roller for a day at the beach, this guide will help you decide. If you prefer a different style, see our picks for the best zipperless cooler.

Comparison at a glance

Key specs · full specs in each pick
Model capacity_qt weight_lb ice_retention_days can_capacity Link
Coleman Marine Cooler with UV Guard Lid & Body 316 Series Cooler 100 qt 17.7 lb 5 days 160 cans View on Amazon
Coleman Classic Series Insulated Portable Wheeled Cooler Classic 100qt Desert Sand 100 qt 18 lb 5 days 167 cans View on Amazon
Coleman Xtreme Rolling Cooler with Wheels, Extra-Walled Insulation Keeps Ice up to 5 Days, Portable Wheeled Hard Chiller 3000005145 50 qt 12.7 lb 5 days 84 cans View on Amazon
Igloo 90-quart Maxcold Latitude Flip and Tow Wheeled Cooler 2622044 90 qt 19.4 lb 5 days 144 cans View on Amazon
Igloo Party Bar Rolling Cooler 44577 120 qt - - 188 cans View on Amazon
Igloo Maxcold Glide 110Qt Wheeled Cooler | Insulated Hard Shell Ice Chest 00034572 110 qt 25.4 lb - 168 cans View on Amazon
IGLOO Maxcold 34814 - 9 lb 5 days - View on Amazon
Igloo 62-quart Maxcold Latitude Roller 2622043 62 qt 14.51 lb 4 days 98 cans View on Amazon
Igloo 00050549 Maxcold Latitude 70 (Ash Gray/Sea/Black) 00050549 - 13.23 lb 5 days - View on Amazon
Igloo Maxcold 40-100 Qt Commercially Insulated Coolers 50303 70 qt 10.6 lb - 114 cans View on Amazon
Igloo Maxcold 40-100 Qt Commercially Insulated Coolers 34696 62 qt 13.9 lb - 98 cans View on Amazon
Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Roller Cooler, Sportsman Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler 52 qt 19.9 lb - 80 cans View on Amazon
Igloo Hard Coolers | Profile II Series | Insulated Ice Chests | Roller Cooler with Wheels 60402 28 qt 8.5 lb - 42 cans View on Amazon
Coleman Marine Cooler with UV Guard Lid & Body
Best overall

1. Coleman 316 Series Cooler

capacity_qt 100 qt weight_lb 17.7 lb ice_retention_days 5 days

Best for: All-around camping and tailgating

The Coleman 316 Series Cooler is a well-rounded wheeled cooler with 100 qt of space and 5 days of ice retention. It holds 160 cans and features a lid that supports up to 250 lb, making it a handy extra seat at the campsite. Cup holders and a drain plug add everyday convenience. While it’s not the lightest option at 17.7 lb, the balance of capacity and features makes it our top overall pick.

Pros

  • Large 100 qt capacity
  • 5 days ice retention
  • Sturdy lid doubles as a seat
  • Built-in cup holders and drain

Cons

  • Heavier than some smaller models
  • Not the largest capacity available
Full specifications (10)
capacity_qt
100 qt
weight_lb
17.7 lb
ice_retention_days
5 days
can_capacity
160 cans
wheeled
Yes
lid_weight_capacity_lb
250 lb
cup_holders
Yes
drain
Yes
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Coleman Classic Series Insulated Portable Wheeled Cooler
Best for extended camping trip

2. Coleman Classic Series Classic 100qt Desert Sand

capacity_qt 100 qt weight_lb 18 lb ice_retention_days 5 days

Best for: Extended camping trips with large groups

The Coleman Classic Series Classic 100qt Desert Sand shares the same 100 qt capacity and 5 days ice retention as the 316 Series but bumps the can count to 167 cans. It rolls on all-terrain wheels and has dual tow and swing-up handles for easy maneuvering. The lid doubles as a seat and includes four molded cup holders. At 18 lb, it’s a solid choice for week-long camping trips where you need to feed a crowd.

Pros

  • Holds up to 167 cans
  • All-terrain wheels
  • Built-in cup holders
  • Lid supports 250 lb

Cons

  • Insulation type not specified
  • Slightly heavier than some
Full specifications (9)
capacity_qt
100 qt
weight_lb
18 lb
ice_retention_days
5 days
can_capacity
167 cans
wheeled
Yes
lid_weight_capacity_lb
250 lb
cup_holders
Yes
drain
Yes
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Coleman Xtreme Rolling Cooler with Wheels, Extra-Walled Insulation Keeps Ice up to 5 Days, Portable Wheeled Hard Chiller
Best for large group tailgate

3. Coleman Xtreme 3000005145

capacity_qt 50 qt weight_lb 12.7 lb ice_retention_days 5 days

Best for: Tailgates and group events

The Coleman Xtreme 3000005145 is a mid-size wheeled cooler with a 50 qt capacity and 84 cans. It keeps ice for 5 days and features a retractable telescoping handle that collapses for compact storage. The lid supports up to 250 lb, so it works as a seat. At just 12.7 lb, it’s easy to lift in and out of a vehicle, making it a great pick for tailgates and day trips.

Pros

  • Lightweight at 12.7 lb
  • Telescoping handle
  • 5 days ice retention
  • Lid supports 250 lb

Cons

  • Smaller capacity than many competitors
  • No cup holders listed
Full specifications (9)
capacity_qt
50 qt
weight_lb
12.7 lb
ice_retention_days
5 days
can_capacity
84 cans
wheeled
Yes
lid_weight_capacity_lb
250 lb
drain
Yes
insulation_type
other
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo 90-quart Maxcold Latitude Flip and Tow Wheeled Cooler
Top ice_retention_days

4. Igloo Maxcold Latitude 2622044

capacity_qt 90 qt weight_lb 19.4 lb ice_retention_days 5 days

Best for: Maximum ice retention on a budget

The Igloo Maxcold Latitude 2622044 delivers 5 days of ice retention in a 90 qt body that holds 144 cans. It rolls on oversized wheels and includes cup holders. While the manufacturer doesn’t list a drain plug or lid weight capacity, the core cooling performance matches the most capable Coleman models. At 19.4 lb, it’s a bit heavier, but the extra capacity makes it a strong value for extended trips.

Pros

  • Large 90 qt capacity
  • 5 days ice retention
  • Cup holders included
  • Holds 144 cans

Cons

  • Drain plug not confirmed
  • Heavier at 19.4 lb
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
90 qt
weight_lb
19.4 lb
ice_retention_days
5 days
can_capacity
144 cans
wheeled
Yes
cup_holders
Yes

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo Party Bar Rolling Cooler
Best for rough terrain transport

5. Igloo Polar-Igloo

capacity_qt 120 qt can_capacity 188 cans wheeled Yes

Best for: Hauling over sand, gravel, and grass

The Igloo Polar-Igloo is the largest cooler in this comparison with a 120 qt capacity and room for 188 cans. It features swing-up handles with tie-down loops and a threaded drain plug for hose hookup. The polyethylene insulation and UV inhibitors add durability. While the weight isn’t specified, a cooler this size will be heavy when full, so the all-terrain wheels are essential for rough terrain transport.

Pros

  • Massive 120 qt capacity
  • Holds 188 cans
  • Swing-up handles with tie-down
  • Threaded drain plug

Cons

  • Weight not listed, likely heavy
  • No cup holders
Full specifications (7)
capacity_qt
120 qt
can_capacity
188 cans
wheeled
Yes
handle_type
swing-up
drain
Yes
insulation_type
polyethylene
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo Maxcold Glide 110Qt Wheeled Cooler | Insulated Hard Shell Ice Chest
#6 pick

6. Igloo Maxcold Glide

capacity_qt 110 qt weight_lb 25.4 lb can_capacity 168 cans

Best for: Large capacity with eco-friendly insulation

The Igloo Maxcold Glide uses THERMECOOL insulation, a cleaner eco-friendly solution, in a 110 qt body that holds 168 cans. It has a telescoping handle, cup holders, and a ruler on the lid. At 25.4 lb, it’s the heaviest model here, so the wheels are a necessity. The lack of a published ice retention rating is a drawback, but the polyurethane foam should perform well.

Pros

  • Eco-friendly insulation
  • Large 110 qt capacity
  • Built-in cup holders
  • Holds 168 cans

Cons

  • Ice retention not specified
  • Heaviest at 25.4 lb
Full specifications (7)
capacity_qt
110 qt
weight_lb
25.4 lb
can_capacity
168 cans
wheeled
Yes
cup_holders
Yes
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

IGLOO Maxcold
#7 pick

7. Igloo Maxcold 34814

weight_lb 9 lb ice_retention_days 5 days wheeled Yes

Best for: Lightweight wheeled cooler for day trips

The Igloo Maxcold 34814 is a featherweight wheeled cooler at just 9 lb, yet it claims 5 days of ice retention. The swing-up handles and wheels make it easy to move, even when full. The manufacturer doesn’t list the capacity in quarts or can count, so it’s best for shorter outings where you don’t need to pack for a crowd.

Pros

  • Very lightweight at 9 lb
  • 5 days ice retention
  • Swing-up handles
  • Wheeled for easy transport

Cons

  • Capacity not listed
  • No cup holders or drain confirmed
Full specifications (6)
weight_lb
9 lb
ice_retention_days
5 days
wheeled
Yes
handle_type
swing-up
insulation_type
other
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo 62-quart Maxcold Latitude Roller
#8 pick

8. Igloo Maxcold Latitude 2622043

capacity_qt 62 qt weight_lb 14.51 lb ice_retention_days 4 days

Best for: Mid-size cooler for weekend camping

The Igloo Maxcold Latitude 2622043 offers a 62 qt capacity and holds 98 cans. It rolls on wheels and includes a telescoping handle, cup holders, and a drain. Ice retention is 4 days, which is a day less than many competitors, but at 14.51 lb it’s easier to lift. It’s a solid choice for a weekend camping trip for two to four people.

Pros

  • Mid-size 62 qt capacity
  • Cup holders and drain
  • Lighter than larger models
  • Wheeled with telescoping handle

Cons

  • Only 4 days ice retention
  • Smaller can capacity
Full specifications (7)
capacity_qt
62 qt
weight_lb
14.51 lb
ice_retention_days
4 days
can_capacity
98 cans
wheeled
Yes
cup_holders
Yes
drain
Yes

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo 00050549 Maxcold Latitude 70 (Ash Gray/Sea/Black)
#9 pick

9. Igloo 00050549

weight_lb 13.23 lb ice_retention_days 5 days handle_type swing-up

Best for: Portable cooler with long ice retention

The Igloo 00050549 promises 5 days of ice retention and features swing-up handles with tie-down loops and a threaded drain plug. At 13.23 lb, it’s easy to carry. However, the manufacturer doesn’t list the capacity in quarts or whether it has wheels, so it’s best for those who prioritize cooling performance and portability over sheer volume.

Pros

  • 5 days ice retention
  • Swing-up handles
  • Threaded drain plug
  • Lightweight at 13.23 lb

Cons

  • Capacity not specified
  • Wheels not confirmed
Full specifications (6)
weight_lb
13.23 lb
ice_retention_days
5 days
handle_type
swing-up
drain
Yes
insulation_type
other
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo Maxcold 40-100 Qt Commercially Insulated Coolers
#10 pick

10. Igloo Maxcold 50303

capacity_qt 70 qt weight_lb 10.6 lb can_capacity 114 cans

Best for: Spacious cooler with swing-up handles

The Igloo Maxcold 50303 provides a 70 qt capacity and holds 114 cans. It uses polyurethane foam insulation and has reinforced swing-up handles. The lack of published ice retention and unconfirmed wheels and drain make it less versatile than some, but at just 10.6 lb, it’s a lightweight option for those who don’t need to roll their cooler.

Pros

  • Lightweight at 10.6 lb
  • 70 qt capacity
  • Polyurethane foam insulation
  • Holds 114 cans

Cons

  • Ice retention not listed
  • No wheels or drain confirmed
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
70 qt
weight_lb
10.6 lb
can_capacity
114 cans
handle_type
swing-up
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo Maxcold 40-100 Qt Commercially Insulated Coolers
#11 pick

11. Igloo Maxcold 34696

capacity_qt 62 qt weight_lb 13.9 lb can_capacity 98 cans

Best for: Durable metal cooler with wheels

The Igloo Maxcold 34696 stands out with a metal body, offering extra durability. It has a 62 qt capacity, holds 98 cans, and includes wheels and cup holders. At 13.9 lb, it’s heavier than similarly sized plastic coolers, but the metal build may appeal to those who prioritize toughness. Ice retention isn’t listed, so plan accordingly.

Pros

  • Durable metal construction
  • Wheeled for easy transport
  • Cup holders included
  • Holds 98 cans

Cons

  • Ice retention not specified
  • Heavier than plastic models
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
62 qt
weight_lb
13.9 lb
can_capacity
98 cans
wheeled
Yes
cup_holders
Yes
material
metal

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Roller Cooler, Sportsman
#12 pick

12. Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler

capacity_qt 52 qt weight_lb 19.9 lb can_capacity 80 cans

Best for: Compact wheeled cooler with thick insulation

The Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler is a 52 qt wheeled cooler with extra-thick foam-insulated walls for extended cooling. It holds 80 cans and features a marine-grade telescoping handle and soft-ride wheels. At 19.9 lb, it’s relatively heavy for its size, but the insulation and build quality make it a durable choice for day trips and small gatherings.

Pros

  • Extra-thick foam insulation
  • Marine-grade telescoping handle
  • Soft-ride wheels
  • Cup holders and drain

Cons

  • Smaller capacity
  • Heavier for its size
Full specifications (8)
capacity_qt
52 qt
weight_lb
19.9 lb
can_capacity
80 cans
wheeled
Yes
cup_holders
Yes
drain
Yes
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo Hard Coolers | Profile II Series | Insulated Ice Chests | Roller Cooler with Wheels
Best for lightweight picnic

13. Igloo Profile II Series 60402

capacity_qt 28 qt weight_lb 8.5 lb can_capacity 42 cans

Best for: Ultra-lightweight picnic cooler

The Igloo Profile II Series 60402 is the most portable option, weighing just 8.5 lb and offering a 28 qt capacity that holds 42 cans. It has built-in wheels and a telescoping handle, plus a drain plug. The trade-off is limited space, so it’s best for solo picnics or short outings where easy transport matters more than volume.

Pros

  • Lightest weight at 8.5 lb
  • Compact and easy to store
  • Built-in wheels
  • Drain plug included

Cons

  • Smallest capacity in the lineup
  • No cup holders
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
28 qt
weight_lb
8.5 lb
can_capacity
42 cans
wheeled
Yes
drain
Yes
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

How to choose

Capacity and can count: how much do you need?

Capacity is measured in quarts and determines how much food and ice you can pack. The Igloo Polar-Igloo leads with 120 qt, while the Igloo Profile II Series 60402 offers a compact 28 qt. For large groups or extended trips, a high-capacity cooler is usually sufficient. Can capacity gives a practical sense of volume: the Igloo Polar-Igloo holds 188 cans, while the Igloo Profile II Series 60402 fits 42 cans. If you need even more space, check out our guide to the best 150 qt cooler.

Ice retention: how long will it stay cold?

Ice retention is the number of days a cooler can keep ice frozen in warm conditions. Many models here claim 5 days, including the Coleman 316 Series Cooler, Coleman Classic Series Classic 100qt Desert Sand, and Igloo Maxcold Latitude 2622044. The Igloo Maxcold Latitude 2622043 is rated at 4 days. Keep in mind that real-world results vary with ambient temperature and lid openings. For maximum ice retention in a rugged design, see our picks for the best rotomolded cooler.

Portability: wheels, handles, and weight

Wheeled coolers are a must for heavy loads. Look for all-terrain wheels and a comfortable handle. The Coleman Xtreme 3000005145 has a telescoping handle that collapses for storage, while the Igloo Polar-Igloo uses swing-up handles with tie-down loops. Weight matters too: the Igloo Profile II Series 60402 is just 8.5 lb, but the Igloo Maxcold Glide weighs 25.4 lb. If portability is your top priority, a best collapsible cooler might be a better fit.

Extra features: cup holders, drains, and lid seats

Cup holders keep drinks secure, and a drain plug makes cleanup easy. The Coleman 316 Series Cooler, Coleman Classic Series Classic 100qt Desert Sand, and Igloo Maxcold Latitude 2622043 include both. A sturdy lid that doubles as a seat is a bonus for tailgates: the Coleman 316 Series Cooler, Coleman Classic Series Classic 100qt Desert Sand, and Coleman Xtreme 3000005145 support up to 250 lb. Not all models list these features, so check the specs if they matter to you.

Frequently asked questions

Which cooler holds ice the longest?

Several models claim 5 days of ice retention, including the Coleman 316 Series Cooler, Coleman Classic Series Classic 100qt Desert Sand, Coleman Xtreme 3000005145, Igloo Maxcold Latitude 2622044, Igloo Maxcold 34814, and Igloo 00050549. The Igloo Maxcold Latitude 2622043 offers 4 days. Real-world performance depends on outside temperature, how often you open the lid, and the quality of the ice.

Can I use these coolers as a seat?

Yes, several models have a lid that supports up to 250 lb, including the Coleman 316 Series Cooler, Coleman Classic Series Classic 100qt Desert Sand, and Coleman Xtreme 3000005145. Always check the manufacturer’s weight limit before sitting.

Are all these coolers wheeled?

Most are wheeled, but a few like the Igloo Maxcold 50303 do not list wheels in their specifications. If easy transport is a priority, look for models with all-terrain wheels and a telescoping or swing-up handle, such as the Coleman Xtreme 3000005145 or Igloo Trailmate 52 Qt Cooler.

What’s the difference between Igloo Maxcold and Coleman Xtreme?

Both brands offer models with 5 days ice retention. Coleman Xtreme coolers often feature telescoping handles and sturdy lids rated to 250 lb. Igloo Maxcold coolers come in a wider range of sizes and insulation types, including eco-friendly options like the Igloo Maxcold Glide. If you’re shopping on a tight budget, see our best cheap cooler picks.

Which is the lightest cooler?

The Igloo Profile II Series 60402 is the lightest at 8.5 lb, making it ideal for short outings and picnics. For a wheeled cooler with more capacity, the Igloo Maxcold 34814 weighs only 9 lb and still offers 5 days of ice retention.

Bottom line

For all-around camping and tailgating, the Coleman 316 Series Cooler is hard to beat with its 100 qt capacity and 5 days of ice retention. If you need maximum space, the Igloo Polar-Igloo holds 188 cans. For a lightweight picnic companion, the Igloo Profile II Series 60402 is the clear choice at just 8.5 lb.