Coolers Ice Retention Test Results

We earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. Learn more.

Quick answer

The LIVICE 25VIPBWX is our top pick for most campers, with a claimed 5 days ice retention and a 26.4 qt capacity. For larger groups, the VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48 offers 50 qt and holds 90 cans.

Our top picks

On this page
  1. Our top picks
  2. Comparison
  3. 1. 25VIPBWX
  4. 2. COB48
  5. 3. 91178
  6. 4. PI-1LB-BLU
  7. 5. HS9222
  8. 6. 120075
  9. 7. RC-RFLBLCLR-BAG01
  10. 8. Trail Mate
  11. 9. B0DY21G888
  12. 10. Miami Ice Packs
  13. 11. ELI-9022
  14. 12. B0FC1M1LVL
  15. 13. 70036BL-CYPO
  16. How to choose
  17. FAQ
  18. Bottom line

Choosing a cooler often comes down to one question: how long will it keep ice? We compared the published ice retention claims, capacities, and features of popular hard coolers and ice packs to help you find the right one for your next trip. Our picks are based entirely on manufacturer specifications and defined use cases. Whether you need a lightweight companion for a picnic or a bear-resistant workhorse for extended camping, this guide breaks down the numbers so you can decide with confidence. If you want a rugged, high-performance option, our best rotomolded cooler picks are worth a look.

Comparison at a glance

Key specs · full specs in each pick
Model capacity_qt weight_lb ice_retention_days can_capacity Link
25L Portable Hard Cooler, 5 Days Ice Retention 25VIPBWX 26.4 qt 9.5 lb 5 days 60 cans View on Amazon
VEVOR Portable Cooler,Hard Cooler with Ice Retention, Heavy-Duty Handles and Strap, Lightweight Rigid Material Insulated Portable Cooler, Suitable for Family Picnics and Short Trips COB48 50 qt 29.1 lb 2 days 90 cans View on Amazon
Lifetime Hard Cooler, High Performance Ice Chest 91178 28 qt 17.4 lb 5 days - View on Amazon
Pelican Ice PI-1LB-BLU - 1 lb - - View on Amazon
Lightweight Rigid Material Insulated Portable Cooler, Suitable for Family Picnics and Short Trips HS9222 24 qt 7.5 lb 2 days 36 cans View on Amazon
Heathrow Scientific True North HEA120075 Polycarbonate Mini Cooler with Gel Filled Lid, Holds 0.5-2 mL x 32 Tubes, -20°C Maximum Temperature 120075 - 1.5 lb - - View on Amazon
6 Pack Refillable Ice Packs for Cooler, Long Lasting Reusable Freezer Packs RC-RFLBLCLR-BAG01 - 1.9 lb - - View on Amazon
Igloo Trailmate Cooler | Insulated Hard Shell Ice Chest Trail Mate 25 qt 10.8 lb - 38 cans View on Amazon
Below Zero Prefilled Reusable Ice Packs for Coolers | Long Lasting Freezer Ice Blocks for Camping, Lunch Bags & More | 48 Hour Cooler Ice Pack Technology B0DY21G888 - 3.24 lb - - View on Amazon
Miami Ice Packs for Coolers - Reusable 12x9 XL Ice Blocks Replace 7lbs of Ice - Long Lasting Freezer Packs, Cooler Accessories, Large Frozen Ice Packs for Cooler Miami Ice Packs - - 4 days - View on Amazon
Reusable Ice Packs for Coolers and Lunch Box, Long Lasting 12 Hours, 4 Pack ELI-9022 - 5.73 lb 0.5 days - View on Amazon
Miami Ice Reusable XL Cooler Ice Pack (12"x9") | Replaces 7 lbs of Ice, Stays Cold 24–48 Hours, BPA-Free, Built-in Handle, Large Frozen Ice Packs for Cooler B0FC1M1LVL - - - - View on Amazon
COSTWAY 16 Quart Cooler, 24 Can Insulated Ice Chest Box with Heavy Duty Handle and 2 Cup Holders, 3-5 Days Ice Retention, Portable Leakproof Hard Cooler for Camping, Fishing, Picnic, Outdoor 70036BL-CYPO 16 qt 13 lb - 24 cans View on Amazon
25L Portable Hard Cooler, 5 Days Ice Retention
Best overall

1. LIVICE 25VIPBWX

capacity_qt 26.4 qt weight_lb 9.5 lb ice_retention_days 5 days

Best for: Weekend camping and picnics

The LIVICE 25VIPBWX is a well-rounded hard cooler that balances ice retention, portability, and convenience. It claims up to 5 days of ice retention, matching the top performers, while weighing just 9.5 lb. Its 26.4 qt capacity holds 60 cans, enough for a small group. A built-in drain, cup holders, and both a metal handle and shoulder strap make it easy to use on the go. Compared to the larger VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48, it sacrifices capacity for much lighter weight, making it a better fit for short trips and picnics.

Pros

  • Up to 5 days ice retention
  • Lightweight at 9.5 lb
  • Dual carry options: handle and strap
  • Drain plug and cup holders

Cons

  • Smaller capacity than large group coolers
  • No lockable lid or bear resistance
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
26.4 qt
weight_lb
9.5 lb
ice_retention_days
5 days
can_capacity
60 cans
cup_holders
Yes
drain
Yes

Specs: Amazon listing

VEVOR Portable Cooler,Hard Cooler with Ice Retention, Heavy-Duty Handles and Strap, Lightweight Rigid Material Insulated Portable Cooler, Suitable for Family Picnics and Short Trips
Top capacity_qt

2. VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48

capacity_qt 50 qt weight_lb 29.1 lb ice_retention_days 2 days

Best for: Tailgating and large family outings

The VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48 is built for big groups. With a 50 qt capacity, it holds 90 cans and includes a dual-zone drawer that keeps dry items separate from ice. Its ice retention is rated at 2 days, which is shorter than the top performers but adequate for a day-long event. The trade-off is weight: at 29.1 lb, it is the heaviest cooler we compared. If you need maximum space and don't plan to carry it far, this is a strong choice.

Pros

  • Massive 50 qt capacity
  • Holds up to 90 cans
  • Dual-zone dry/wet drawer
  • Built-in cup holders

Cons

  • Heavy at 29.1 lb
  • Shorter ice retention than top performers
  • No drain plug listed
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
50 qt
weight_lb
29.1 lb
ice_retention_days
2 days
can_capacity
90 cans
cup_holders
Yes
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

Lifetime Hard Cooler, High Performance Ice Chest
Top ice_retention_days

3. Lifetime 28 Quart High Performance Cooler

capacity_qt 28 qt weight_lb 17.4 lb ice_retention_days 5 days

Best for: Extended camping in bear country

The Lifetime 28 Quart High Performance Cooler is a rugged, bear-resistant hard cooler that prioritizes ice retention and durability over convenience features. It claims up to 5 days of ice retention, tying with the LIVICE 25VIPBWX for the top spot. Its 28 qt capacity is modest, and it lacks a drain, cup holders, and a listed can count. At 17.4 lb, it is heavier than the LIVICE 25VIPBWX but still manageable. This cooler is ideal for backcountry trips where security and long-lasting cold are critical.

Pros

  • Bear-resistant certification
  • Up to 5 days ice retention
  • Durable polyethylene construction

Cons

  • No drain plug or cup holders
  • Heavier than similar-sized coolers
  • Can capacity not specified
Full specifications (5)
capacity_qt
28 qt
weight_lb
17.4 lb
ice_retention_days
5 days
insulation_type
polyethylene
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Pelican Ice
Lowest weight_lb

4. Pelican Ice Block PI-1LB-BLU

weight_lb 1 lb insulation_type polyurethane-foam material plastic

Best for: Pelican cooler owners needing extra ice retention

The Pelican Ice Block PI-1LB-BLU is a reusable ice block designed to fit Pelican coolers, though it can be used in other brands. It weighs just 1 lb and features a UV-protective shell. As an ice pack, it helps chill contents faster and stay colder longer, but it is not a cooler itself. If you already own a Pelican cooler and want to boost ice retention, this is a purpose-built accessory.

Pros

  • Lightweight at 1 lb
  • Custom fit for Pelican coolers
  • UV protective shell

Cons

  • Not a standalone cooler
  • Limited to ice pack function
  • No capacity or ice retention data
Full specifications (3)
weight_lb
1 lb
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Lightweight Rigid Material Insulated Portable Cooler, Suitable for Family Picnics and Short Trips
Best for lightweight picnic

5. VEVOR Hard Cooler HS9222

capacity_qt 24 qt weight_lb 7.5 lb ice_retention_days 2 days

Best for: Day trips and picnics

The VEVOR Hard Cooler HS9222 is a compact, lightweight hard cooler perfect for short outings. At just 7.5 lb, it is easy to carry, yet its 24 qt capacity holds 36 cans. The 3-layer insulation helps it achieve 2 days of ice retention, which is enough for a day at the beach or a picnic. It lacks some convenience features like a drain and cup holders, but its portability and leak-resistant design make it a practical choice for casual use.

Pros

  • Very lightweight at 7.5 lb
  • 24 qt capacity holds 36 cans
  • 3-layer PU foam insulation
  • Leak-resistant sealing

Cons

  • Shorter ice retention at 2 days
  • No drain or cup holders listed
  • Smaller capacity than family-sized coolers
Full specifications (6)
capacity_qt
24 qt
weight_lb
7.5 lb
ice_retention_days
2 days
can_capacity
36 cans
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Heathrow Scientific True North HEA120075 Polycarbonate Mini Cooler with Gel Filled Lid, Holds 0.5-2 mL x 32 Tubes, -20°C Maximum Temperature
#6 pick

6. Heathrow Scientific True North 120075

weight_lb 1.5 lb insulation_type other material plastic

Best for: Laboratory sample cooling

The Heathrow Scientific True North 120075 is a benchtop cooler built for lab use, not camping. Its polycarbonate construction and gel-filled lid keep reagents and samples cold at precise temperatures. It weighs 1.5 lb and includes a gridded lid for easy sample tracking. While it excels in a clinical setting, it lacks the capacity, ice retention claims, and features needed for outdoor food and drink storage.

Pros

  • Precise temperature control for lab samples
  • Non-slip rubber feet
  • Gridded lid for sample identification

Cons

  • Not designed for food or beverages
  • Very small capacity
  • No ice retention data for outdoor use
Full specifications (3)
weight_lb
1.5 lb
insulation_type
other
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

6 Pack Refillable Ice Packs for Cooler, Long Lasting Reusable Freezer Packs
#7 pick

7. RidgeCool RC-RFLBLCLR-BAG01

weight_lb 1.9 lb insulation_type polyethylene material other

Best for: Supplementing ice in any cooler

The RidgeCool RC-RFLBLCLR-BAG01 is a set of six refillable ice packs that you fill with water and freeze. They are designed to replace loose ice, reducing mess and saving space in your cooler. Each pack weighs 1.9 lb and provides broad cooling coverage. While they don't have a stated ice retention time, they are a practical, reusable solution for keeping food and drinks cold on short trips.

Pros

  • Set of 6 large ice packs
  • Spill-free filling with included funnel
  • Reusable and cleaner than loose ice

Cons

  • Require freezing before use
  • Not a standalone cooler
  • No ice retention data
Full specifications (3)
weight_lb
1.9 lb
insulation_type
polyethylene
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

Igloo Trailmate Cooler | Insulated Hard Shell Ice Chest
#8 pick

8. Igloo Trailmate Trail Mate

capacity_qt 25 qt weight_lb 10.8 lb can_capacity 38 cans

Best for: Casual day use and picnics

The Igloo Trailmate Trail Mate is a classic hard cooler with a 25 qt capacity that holds 38 cans. It includes a drain plug and cup holders, and its bail handle makes it easy to carry. At 10.8 lb, it is light enough for everyday use. The manufacturer does not publish an ice retention time, so it is best suited for day trips where you can replenish ice as needed.

Pros

  • Lightweight at 10.8 lb
  • Drain plug and cup holders
  • Swing-up bail handle

Cons

  • No ice retention spec available
  • Smaller capacity than large coolers
  • Insulation type not specified
Full specifications (8)
capacity_qt
25 qt
weight_lb
10.8 lb
can_capacity
38 cans
handle_type
bail
cup_holders
Yes
drain
Yes
insulation_type
other
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Below Zero Prefilled Reusable Ice Packs for Coolers | Long Lasting Freezer Ice Blocks for Camping, Lunch Bags & More | 48 Hour Cooler Ice Pack Technology
#9 pick

9. BelowZero Reusable Ice Packs

weight_lb 3.24 lb material plastic

Best for: Keeping food cold in lunch boxes or small coolers

The BelowZero Reusable Ice Packs is a reusable gel ice pack that promises up to 48 hours of cooling. It weighs 3.24 lb and is designed to fit in lunch boxes and small coolers. While it lacks detailed specs like capacity or ice retention days, its gel formula is meant to outperform regular ice. It is a simple, no-fuss accessory for keeping perishables cold on short outings.

Pros

  • Long-lasting gel formula
  • Reusable and leakproof
  • Non-toxic materials

Cons

  • No capacity or ice retention data
  • Just an ice pack, not a cooler
  • Heavier than some alternatives
Full specifications (2)
weight_lb
3.24 lb
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Miami Ice Packs for Coolers - Reusable 12x9 XL Ice Blocks Replace 7lbs of Ice - Long Lasting Freezer Packs, Cooler Accessories, Large Frozen Ice Packs for Cooler
#10 pick

10. HealthyPackers Miami Ice Packs

ice_retention_days 4 days material plastic

Best for: Replacing loose ice in large coolers

The HealthyPackers Miami Ice Packs is a large reusable ice pack that claims up to 4 days of ice retention, designed to replace loose ice. It is designed to maximize contact with cooler walls and includes a built-in handle for easy loading. While it is not a cooler itself, it can significantly extend the cold life of your existing cooler when pre-frozen.

Pros

  • Up to 4 days ice retention
  • Generous size for broad cooling coverage
  • Reusable and BPA-free

Cons

  • Requires filling and freezing
  • Weight not specified
  • No cooler capacity
Full specifications (2)
ice_retention_days
4 days
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

Reusable Ice Packs for Coolers and Lunch Box, Long Lasting 12 Hours, 4 Pack
#11 pick

11. EverlastingIceRX ELI-9022

weight_lb 5.73 lb ice_retention_days 0.5 days material other

Best for: Short lunch box use

The EverlastingIceRX ELI-9022 is a reusable gel ice pack with a slim profile that fits easily into lunch boxes. Its claimed ice retention is only 0.5 days, which is the shortest among the ice packs we compared. At 5.73 lb, it is also relatively heavy for its size. It works for keeping a single meal cold but is not suitable for all-day cooling.

Pros

  • Slim, flat design
  • Reusable and non-toxic
  • Puncture-resistant

Cons

  • Very short ice retention at 0.5 days
  • Heavy for an ice pack at 5.73 lb
  • No capacity or cooler function
Full specifications (3)
weight_lb
5.73 lb
ice_retention_days
0.5 days
material
other

Specs: Amazon listing

Miami Ice Reusable XL Cooler Ice Pack (12"x9") | Replaces 7 lbs of Ice, Stays Cold 24–48 Hours, BPA-Free, Built-in Handle, Large Frozen Ice Packs for Cooler
#12 pick

12. HealthyPackers Miami Ice

insulation_type polyurethane-foam material plastic

Best for: Cooler organization and ice replacement

The HealthyPackers Miami Ice is another reusable ice pack from HealthyPackers, similar to the HealthyPackers Miami Ice Packs but without a published ice retention time. It is designed to be filled with water, frozen, and placed in a cooler to replace loose ice. Its large size and handle make it easy to position. Without a stated duration, it is best used as a supplement to other cooling methods.

Pros

  • Generous size fits most coolers
  • Built-in carry handle
  • BPA-free, food-safe materials

Cons

  • No ice retention spec
  • Weight not listed
  • Not a standalone cooler
Full specifications (2)
insulation_type
polyurethane-foam
material
plastic

Specs: Amazon listing

COSTWAY 16 Quart Cooler, 24 Can Insulated Ice Chest Box with Heavy Duty Handle and 2 Cup Holders, 3-5 Days Ice Retention, Portable Leakproof Hard Cooler for Camping, Fishing, Picnic, Outdoor
#13 pick

13. COSTWAY 70036BL-CYPO

capacity_qt 16 qt weight_lb 13 lb can_capacity 24 cans

Best for: Solo outings or short trips

The COSTWAY 70036BL-CYPO is a small, rotomolded hard cooler with a 16 qt capacity that holds 24 cans. It includes a drain plug, cup holders, and a padded handle for comfortable carrying. At 13 lb, it is not the lightest for its size, and the manufacturer does not provide an ice retention claim. It is a sturdy choice for a single person's day trip.

Pros

  • Compact and durable
  • Drain plug and cup holders
  • Padded stainless steel handle

Cons

  • Small 16 qt capacity
  • No ice retention spec
  • Heavier than some larger coolers
Full specifications (5)
capacity_qt
16 qt
weight_lb
13 lb
can_capacity
24 cans
cup_holders
Yes
drain
Yes

Specs: Amazon listing

How to choose

Understanding ice retention claims

Manufacturers state ice retention in days under ideal conditions. The LIVICE 25VIPBWX and Lifetime 28 Quart High Performance Cooler both claim 5 days, while many budget models offer around 2 days. These numbers assume a full cooler, minimal opening, and shade. In practice, expect less. If you need multi-day cold without ice, see our best iceless cooler options. For the longest claims, look for thick insulation and a tight-sealing lid.

Capacity: how much space do you need?

Capacity is measured in quarts or by can count. A 24 qt cooler like the VEVOR Hard Cooler HS9222 holds 36 cans and suits a solo day trip. The VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48 offers 50 qt and fits 90 cans, enough for a large group tailgate. Think about how many people and how long you will be out. For massive capacity, check our best 150 qt cooler picks. Remember, more capacity often means more weight.

Weight and portability

An empty cooler’s weight matters when you have to carry it any distance. The VEVOR Hard Cooler HS9222 weighs only 7.5 lb, while the VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48 is a hefty 29.1 lb. If you need to move a cooler over sand or trails, look for a lightweight design with comfortable handles. The LIVICE 25VIPBWX includes both a metal handle and a shoulder strap. For the lightest hard-sided option, the Pelican Ice Block PI-1LB-BLU is just 1 lb but is an ice pack, not a full cooler.

Features that matter: drains, cup holders, and handles

A drain plug makes cleaning and emptying meltwater easy; the LIVICE 25VIPBWX, Igloo Trailmate Trail Mate, and COSTWAY 70036BL-CYPO all include one. Cup holders on the lid, found on the LIVICE 25VIPBWX and VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48, keep drinks handy. Handles vary from simple bail styles to padded grips. If you camp in bear country, a certified bear-resistant cooler like the Lifetime 28 Quart High Performance Cooler adds security. For a budget-friendly option with these features, see our best cheap cooler roundup.

Frequently asked questions

How long do coolers really keep ice?

Ice retention depends on insulation, ambient temperature, and how often the cooler is opened. Based on manufacturer claims, some hard coolers like the LIVICE 25VIPBWX and Lifetime 28 Quart High Performance Cooler are rated for up to 5 days, while smaller ice packs like the EverlastingIceRX ELI-9022 may only last 0.5 days. Real-world results will vary with use.

What is the best cooler for a weekend camping trip?

For a weekend camping trip, look for a cooler with at least 5 days of claimed ice retention and enough capacity for your group. The LIVICE 25VIPBWX holds 60 cans and weighs just 9.5 lb, making it easy to carry to a campsite. If you need more space, the VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48 offers 50 qt.

Are reusable ice packs better than loose ice?

Reusable ice packs like the HealthyPackers Miami Ice Packs and BelowZero Reusable Ice Packs can replace loose ice and avoid soggy food. They are designed to freeze solid and stay cold for up to 4 days in some cases. However, they take up space and need to be pre-frozen, so they work best when combined with regular ice or in coolers with good insulation.

What size cooler do I need for a family of four?

A family of four typically needs a cooler that can hold at least 40-50 cans. The VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48 fits 90 cans and has a dual-zone drawer to separate drinks from food. For shorter outings, the VEVOR Hard Cooler HS9222 holds 36 cans and is much lighter at 7.5 lb, making it easier to carry to a picnic spot.

Bottom line

For weekend trips and everyday use, the LIVICE 25VIPBWX balances ice retention and portability. Large groups will appreciate the VEVOR Hard Cooler COB48 for its sheer capacity, while the Lifetime 28 Quart High Performance Cooler is the go-to for bear-country camping. If you just need to supplement ice, the HealthyPackers Miami Ice Packs and BelowZero Reusable Ice Packs offer reusable convenience.