Quick answer
If you're torn between charcoal and propane, the Volcano 3 VL-20-300 solves the dilemma by using both fuels. It's collapsible, weighs just 4 lb, and suits campers who want flexibility. For a dedicated charcoal grill, the Charmline CL-PGL is a compact, no-assembly option.
Our top picks
Best overall
Volcano 3 VL-20-300
Campers who want both charcoal flavor and propane convenience
#2 pick
Charmline CL-PGL
Charcoal purists who want a simple, portable grill
On this page
Choosing between charcoal and propane for your camping grill can shape your entire outdoor cooking experience. This guide is for campers who want to decide which fuel type, or a combination, fits their style. We compared the specifications and features of portable grills to find the best options for different needs. Our top pick, the Volcano 3 VL-20-300, stands out because it handles propane, charcoal, and even wood, giving you the best of both worlds. For those who love the smoky flavor of charcoal and want a simple, packable design, the Charmline CL-PGL is a strong contender. Every pick is based on manufacturer specifications and defined use cases.
Comparison at a glance
| Model | weight | collapsible | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
|
|
4 lb | Yes | View on Amazon |
|
|
5 lb | Yes | View on Amazon |
Best for: Campers who want both charcoal flavor and propane convenience
The Volcano 3 VL-20-300 is a versatile camping grill that eliminates the charcoal vs propane debate by supporting both fuels, plus wood. It folds down small for storage and includes a carrying bag. Weighing 4 lb, it's easy to transport to any campsite. The Yes design and included propane burner make it ready for quick meals or slow smoking. Compared to the Charmline CL-PGL, it offers more cooking flexibility but requires managing multiple fuel components. This is the grill for campers who want one device that adapts to any situation.
Pros
- Uses propane, charcoal, or wood
- Folds down small for storage
- Lightweight at 4 lb
- Includes propane burner and accessories
Cons
- Requires a separate propane tank (not included)
- More complex setup than a dedicated charcoal grill
- Steel construction needs regular care to prevent rust
Best for: Charcoal purists who want a simple, portable grill
The Charmline CL-PGL is a dedicated charcoal grill that folds down to the size of a sheet of paper for easy transport. It requires no assembly, just unfold and start cooking. Weighing 5 lb, it's slightly heavier than the Volcano 3 VL-20-300 but still portable. The Yes design and included sauce shelf make it a practical choice for small groups. Unlike the multi-fuel Volcano, this grill focuses purely on charcoal, delivering that classic smoky taste without the complexity of propane. It's ideal for purists who want a simple, no-fuss grilling experience.
Pros
- No assembly required
- Folds to a compact size for storage
- Dedicated charcoal grilling for authentic flavor
- Includes a convenient sauce shelf
Cons
- Charcoal only, no propane option
- Heavier than the Volcano 3 at 5 lb
- Small cooking surface for 1-3 people
- Steel construction may rust if not maintained
How to choose
Charcoal vs propane: flavor or convenience?
Charcoal delivers a smoky flavor and high searing heat that many campers love, but it takes time to light and leaves ash to clean up. Propane offers push-button ignition, instant heat, and precise temperature control with no ash. The Volcano 3 VL-20-300 bridges the gap by supporting both fuels, plus wood. If you want the option to slow-smoke ribs over charcoal one night and quickly boil water with propane the next, a multi-fuel grill is the way to go. The Charmline CL-PGL is a dedicated charcoal grill for purists who don't need propane.
Portability: weight and packed size
When space is tight, every pound and inch counts. Both the Volcano 3 VL-20-300 and Charmline CL-PGL collapse for storage, but the Volcano is lighter at 4 lb compared to the Charmline's 5 lb. The Volcano collapses to a very compact size, while the Charmline packs down to roughly the size of a letter-size sheet of paper. For car camping, either works well. If you're hiking a short distance to a campsite, the lighter Volcano has a slight edge.
Cooking surface and capacity
Cooking area determines how much food you can prepare at once. The Volcano 3 VL-20-300 provides a round grilling surface that fits several burgers or steaks, while the Charmline CL-PGL is designed for 1-3 people. If you often cook for a group, the Volcano gives you more room. For solo campers or couples, the Charmline's compact grate is plenty. Keep in mind that charcoal grills need space for both direct and indirect heat zones, so a slightly larger grate can be helpful even for small meals.
Ease of setup and cleanup
Setup time varies between models. The Charmline CL-PGL requires no assembly, just unfold it and start cooking. The Volcano 3 VL-20-300 needs you to choose a fuel source and install the appropriate burner or grate, which takes a few extra minutes but gives you more cooking options. Cleanup is simpler with propane since there's no ash, but charcoal grills like the Charmline have smooth surfaces that wipe down easily. Consider how much time you want to spend on setup and post-meal chores.
Frequently asked questions
Is charcoal or propane better for camping?
It depends on your priorities. Charcoal gives food a smoky flavor and a traditional grilling experience, but it takes longer to heat and requires ash cleanup. Propane heats up quickly, offers consistent temperature control, and leaves no ash, but lacks that smoky taste. The Volcano 3 VL-20-300 lets you use either fuel, so you don't have to choose.
Can I use both charcoal and propane in the same camping grill?
Only multi-fuel grills like the Volcano 3 VL-20-300 are designed to use both charcoal and propane. Most portable camping grills are dedicated to one fuel type. If you want the flexibility to switch, look for a model that explicitly supports multiple fuels.
How do I clean a portable camping grill?
Both the Volcano 3 VL-20-300 and Charmline CL-PGL have steel construction that needs regular care. After each use, remove ash from charcoal grills and wipe down surfaces. For propane components, follow the manufacturer's cleaning instructions. Proper maintenance prevents rust and extends the life of your grill.
Are collapsible camping grills durable?
Yes, when built with quality materials. The Volcano 3 VL-20-300 and Charmline CL-PGL use steel and are designed for repeated outdoor use. They fold down for storage but remain sturdy when set up. To keep them durable, store them dry and clean them after each trip.
What size camping grill do I need for a family of four?
For families, look for a grill with a larger cooking surface. The Volcano 3 VL-20-300 offers more cooking area than the Charmline CL-PGL, but both are best suited for small groups. The Charmline is designed for 1-3 people, while the Volcano 3 can handle a few more burgers at once. If you regularly cook for four or more, consider a larger model.
Bottom line
If you can't decide between charcoal and propane, the Volcano 3 VL-20-300 is the clear choice, it handles both with ease and packs down small. For those who love the ritual and flavor of charcoal and want a grab-and-go design, the Charmline CL-PGL delivers simplicity and portability. Both are solid camping companions; your choice comes down to fuel flexibility versus dedicated charcoal cooking.